Skip to main content
Sicily by Car logo

Sicily by Car reviews & trust report

Sicily by Car is a vehicle transportation company specializing in car rental services across Sicily, Italy. The company offers a diverse range of vehicles to meet the needs of tourists and locals alike, providing options for various budgets and preferences. Customers can conveniently book their desired vehicles through the company’s website, www.sicilybycar.it, ensuring a seamless rental experience. Targeting travelers exploring the beautiful landscapes of Sicily, Sicily by Car aims to facilitate easy mobility for individuals, families, and groups. The company is committed to providing reliable transportation solutions, enabling customers to discover Sicily’s attractions at their own pace. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Sicily by Car strives to deliver a straightforward and user-friendly car rental process.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Sicily by Car has a positive customer experience.

Sicily by Car receives predominantly positive feedback, with many customers praising the cleanliness and quality of the vehicles, as well as the efficiency of the check-in and check-out processes. Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and professional staff, noting quick service and helpfulness during their rentals.

Read full summary

However, some customers express frustration regarding the requirement for a credit card for deposits, which led to complications for those with debit cards. Additionally, there are complaints about unexpected fees, such as charges for tire damage that were not clearly communicated upfront. Despite these issues, the overall sentiment remains favorable, with many recommending the service for its reliability and good vehicle condition. Overall, Sicily by Car is viewed positively by the majority of its customers.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
2 of 2 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.4/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 84% happy · 11% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Returns
  • Charges
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.4
100%
4.4 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
4.4
12-month avg
4.4
All-time
4.4
Category avg
3.8
1.02.03.04.05.0Jun 25Jul 25Category avg 3.8Jun 25: 4.5 from 242 reviewsJul 25: 4.4 from 758 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Jun 254.5242
Jul 254.4758

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 419 positive reviews

  • Customer service11%
    48 mentions
  • Fast & efficient11%
    47 mentions
  • Easy to use9%
    36 mentions
  • Friendly staff6%
    26 mentions
“Almost new car”
On “Customer service” · Jul 18, 2025

Top complaintsof 57 negative reviews

  • Payment issues25%
    14 mentions
  • Returns19%
    11 mentions
  • Charges16%
    9 mentions
  • Customer service16%
    9 mentions
“We burst a tyre on the motorway due to”
On “Payment issues” · Jul 18, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vehicles & Transportation.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Sicily by Car logo
Sicily by Car
4.4 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,999
4.1 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
3.6 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: Sicily by Car is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, BJS Home Delivery scores higher (4.6 vs 3.6).

Reviews

500 reviews of Sicily by Car. Filter by what matters to you.

4.4ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
VALLANCE NICHOLAS

Room for improvement at hire desk.

Overall our experience was very good. The car was very clean and worked very reliably. The returns experience was excellent and the staff there were welcoming and professional. However at the initial hire desk the staff we met were not so welcoming or particularly helpful.

Report
MORGANTI MATTEO

Servizio rapido e senza intoppi

Servizio rapido e senza intoppi. La macchina fornitami era pulita e ordinata.

Report
Pa Wel
Pa Wel
1 review

In Catania airport, hostile and unpleasant staff! Fire this girl on the spot!

In Catania airport we booked car: Compact: Cupra Born or similar, CDAE/CDAE 5 seats, 4 doors, Air Conditioning, Automatic , Electric At the desk there was very hostile and unpleasant girl shouting at us that we didn't booked Cupra, after an argument her colleague also started shouting at us. At the we as family of four with our baggage was given small citroen! She told us that they dont have car we booked, but after we went to collection point there was at least two cupra born parked there! The staff need to be fired for such customer service... Wont be booking or recommending this company to anyone. Will be following up with this case after the holidays.

Report
Pa
Pa
1 review

Veloci e gentili a brindisi

Veloci e gentili a brindisi

Report
Janine van Lieshout

Oplichters

Afgelopen week een auto gehuurd in Kroatië.Tip: controleer de auto heel goed. Ook de onderkant van de bumpers. Daar zat bij ons een schade welke niet te zien was op t filmpje dat ik gemaakt had. Bij het ophalen van de auto wordt netjes heel de auto nagelopen behalve de onderkant van de bumpers. Bij het inleveren werd dat als eerste gedaan. Je krijgt meteen t gevoel dat je erin geluisd wordt. Ze wisten dat ik een verzekering elders had afgesloten. Er wordt ook gelijk een schadebedrag genoemd . Maar je hebt zelf geen bewijs dus helaas betalen. Enorme domper van je vakantie. Dus of je auto heel goed controleren inclusief onderkant maar beter nog; GEEN zaken met ze doen : OPLICHTERS.

Report
Alberto
Alberto
1 review

Servizio efficiente a costi contenuti

Servizio efficiente a costi contenuti

Report
VERBRUGGEN ERWIN M K

Thumbs up for Sicilybycar

When we arrived at the terminal we went straight to the rental desk…with lots of other people. Although tree people were helping for the paperwork we had to wait 1,5 hours before it was our turn. Nevertheless a very friendly lady at the desk and at the point where we had to collect the car. Excellent new car. Would certainly rent here again. Thanks Sicilybycar!

Report
John Boal
John Boal
1 review

The car hire company of choice in Italy. …

Once again Sicily by Car delivered the goods. Trouble-free pick up and return; beautifully presented car, clear documentation and no surprises. Good value and ever reliable. For me, the car hire company of choice in Italy. Look no further.

Report
GIORGIO AGNOLETTI

Tutto andato bene dal ritiro dei…

Tutto andato bene dal ritiro dei documenti alla consegna dell auto e alla riconsegna. Gentili ed aducati

Report
STEFANI EGIDIO

Con Sicily by car viaggi protetto

Ho trovato il personale (segretaria e addetti) molto gentili e attenti alle esigenze. Vorrei segnalare la segretaria Gaia Curaci per la disponibilità alle mie tante domande. Il furgone che ho prenotato era in ottime condizioni!

Report
Michela P
Michela P
1 review

Esperienza pessima

Esperienza pessima. Abbiamo atteso un'ora per ritirare una macchina già prenotata e pagata. Il personale allo sportello è assolutamente incompetente e cafone, e hanno insistito per prendere 300€ di caparra nonostante il contratto indicasse 100€ dato che abbiamo pagato l'assicurazione più completa. Abbiamo assistito a due signore che hanno quasi perso il volo per colpa dell'incompetenza del personale. Ti danno risposte arroganti e inconcludenti, finché per sfinimento non acconsenti a quello che vogliono loro. In più la macchina ci è stata consegnata sporca.

Report
David Barton
David Barton
1 review

Good all round

Have used many times . Reception very nice Return quick and nice people

Report
Paolo
Paolo
1 review

Prezzi OK ma tempi KO

Buoni i prezzi relativamente alla qualità del servizio offerto. Peccato i tempi di attesa biblici per il check-in all´arrivo ad Alghero. Un´ora esatta per servire 6 clienti. Inammissibile

Report
Nicola
Nicola
1 review

Servizio raccomandato

ottimo servizio cortesia e disponibilita'

Report
Mg
Mg
1 review

Staff gentile e competente

Autovettura nuova. Procedure veloci e personale gentile

Report
BAUER NORBERT

Quick and good Service

Quick and good Service. Could improve: 1.) Chosen car is different you get 2.) pick up Place is on top floor. It means, car is very hot. If you have manual or weak air condition, not nice

Report
Dirk Apers
Dirk Apers
1 review

The most hostile “customer service” I’ve encountered in years

I prepaid a one-week rental with SicilyByCar and arrived with every document in hand at Bologna airport, only to be stone-walled at every turn: Debit-vs-credit card standoff – The agent refused my Mastercard because it’s technically a debit card, even though it has never been rejected elsewhere and the booking site never flagged this as an issue. No alternative payment accepted – When I offered my travel companion’s credit card for the security hold, I was told that would require adding him as a driver—“not possible”. I then proposed paying the €200 deposit outright in cash or by card. Also “not possible”. Zero flexibility—even for a day – I offered to return the next morning with a different credit card. They still refused, claiming they wouldn’t hold the vehicle despite my having already paid for the full week. Needlessly hostile tone – Every suggestion (paying extra fees, changing the booking, fetching another card) was met with curt, dismissive replies. No effort to find a solution—just “computer says no.” Fortunately, Booking.com intervened and cancelled the reservation, so at least I recovered my money. But I lost valuable holiday hours scrambling for a replacement car. Bottom line: If you value time, courtesy or the slightest trace of flexibility, avoid SicilyByCar entirely. There are plenty of rental firms in Italy that still understand the meaning of customer service.

Report
Raffaele Becchimanzi

Macchina quasi nuova e check in veloce.

Macchina quasi nuova e check in veloce. Al ritorno grande disponibilità di Vincenzo, che ha chiuso la pratica molto velocemente con chiarezza e professionalità.

Report
GD
GD
1 review

Reasonable cost relative to other providers

Reasonable cost relative to other providers and good choice of cars. Pick-up process at Perugia airport was very slow and charging ~€50 for a speedy pick-up option seemed both cheeky and ineffective (couldn’t see evidence of any customers’ rentals being processed more quickly). By contrast, the return process was quick and simple. No fuss even though we arrived slightly after the booked return time.

Report
Dario Mastrogiacomo

Non mi è piaciuto proprio nulla

Non mi è piaciuto proprio nulla. Viaggio spesso e spesso noleggio auto. Ho noleggiato 3 volte con questa compagnia e tutte le volte qualcosa non è andato bene. non la consiglio.

Report

Sicily by Car FAQ

Quick answers to the questions people ask most.

Is Sicily by Car a legitimate company?

Yes, Sicily by Car is a legitimate company with numerous verified customer reviews and an overall high rating. Many customers have praised the clean vehicles, friendly service, and efficient check-in and check-out processes.

Is Sicily by Car a scam?

No, Sicily by Car is not a scam. Customer feedback indicates that while there are occasional complaints, the majority of reviews are positive, highlighting reliable service and good vehicle conditions.

What services does Sicily by Car offer?

Sicily by Car offers vehicle rental services, including a variety of car models suitable for different needs. Customers have reported quick service and the availability of clean, well-maintained vehicles.

What payment methods does Sicily by Car accept?

Sicily by Car primarily accepts credit cards for rentals. Some customers have noted issues when using debit cards, which may incur additional fees at pick-up.

All 5 questions →

How can I contact customer support for Sicily by Car?

You can contact Sicily by Car's customer support through their website or at the rental locations. Many reviews mention friendly and helpful staff ready to assist with inquiries.

Alternatives to Sicily by Car

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.