Skip to main content
Sicily by Car logo

Sicily by Car reviews & trust report

Sicily by Car is a vehicle transportation company specializing in car rental services across Sicily, Italy. The company offers a diverse range of vehicles to meet the needs of tourists and locals alike, providing options for various budgets and preferences. Customers can conveniently book their desired vehicles through the company’s website, www.sicilybycar.it, ensuring a seamless rental experience. Targeting travelers exploring the beautiful landscapes of Sicily, Sicily by Car aims to facilitate easy mobility for individuals, families, and groups. The company is committed to providing reliable transportation solutions, enabling customers to discover Sicily’s attractions at their own pace. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Sicily by Car strives to deliver a straightforward and user-friendly car rental process.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Sicily by Car has a positive customer experience.

Sicily by Car receives predominantly positive feedback, with many customers praising the cleanliness and quality of the vehicles, as well as the efficiency of the check-in and check-out processes. Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and professional staff, noting quick service and helpfulness during their rentals.

Read full summary

However, some customers express frustration regarding the requirement for a credit card for deposits, which led to complications for those with debit cards. Additionally, there are complaints about unexpected fees, such as charges for tire damage that were not clearly communicated upfront. Despite these issues, the overall sentiment remains favorable, with many recommending the service for its reliability and good vehicle condition. Overall, Sicily by Car is viewed positively by the majority of its customers.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
2 of 2 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.4/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 84% happy · 11% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Returns
  • Charges
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.4
100%
4.4 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
4.4
12-month avg
4.4
All-time
4.4
Category avg
3.8
1.02.03.04.05.0Jun 25Jul 25Category avg 3.8Jun 25: 4.5 from 242 reviewsJul 25: 4.4 from 758 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Jun 254.5242
Jul 254.4758

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 419 positive reviews

  • Customer service11%
    48 mentions
  • Fast & efficient11%
    47 mentions
  • Easy to use9%
    36 mentions
  • Friendly staff6%
    26 mentions
“Almost new car”
On “Customer service” · Jul 18, 2025

Top complaintsof 57 negative reviews

  • Payment issues25%
    14 mentions
  • Returns19%
    11 mentions
  • Charges16%
    9 mentions
  • Customer service16%
    9 mentions
“We burst a tyre on the motorway due to”
On “Payment issues” · Jul 18, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vehicles & Transportation.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Sicily by Car logo
Sicily by Car
4.4 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,999
4.1 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
3.6 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: Sicily by Car is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, BJS Home Delivery scores higher (4.6 vs 3.6).

Reviews

500 reviews of Sicily by Car. Filter by what matters to you.

4.4ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
CRI CRI
CRI CRI
1 review
Featured

Esperienza disastrosa

Esperienza disastrosa. Non c’è stato verso di ritirare la macchina, già pagata, perché non avevamo carta di credito, ma 5 dico ben 5 carte di debito per il deposito cauzionale. Ci siamo offerti di pagare in contanti, con bb istantaneo, di sottoscrivere un’assicurazione a pagamento, come fanno le altre compagnie di noleggio, ma nulla da fare. Tra l’altro ci è stato reso impossibile il ritiro dell’auto il giorno dopo, dopo aver contattato la banca per attivare una carta di credito mai usata che avevamo (era domenica), perché avevamo il pacchetto easy-jet volo con noleggio: dovevamo ritirare la macchina subito o l’avrebbero data ad altri. Pessima compagnia e pessimo servizio nella mia esperienza personale. Mai più….

Report
tim murphy
tim murphy
1 review

Returned the car to Pisa airport at…

Returned the car to Pisa airport at 7.50 am nothing open leave car in bay as directed no one checked car but me. Nothing wrong with car but dusty. Funny old world now charging an extortionate amount for dust . Their photos don’t prove anything . Please AVOID THIS FIRM .

Report
Laurens
Laurens
1 review

Poor experience with Sicily by Car

Poor experience with Sicily by Car – unclear process and unexpected damage charges We recently rented a car from Sicily by Car at Catania Airport and had a very disappointing experience. There was no in-person handover or inspection, everything was done digitally. That meant we had no chance to check for existing damage, and no one reviewed the condition of the car with us before we drove off. After dropping off the car early in the morning (around 6:00 AM) by placing the keys in the return box – as instructed – we received a message shortly afterwards claiming that there was new damage to the car, and that we had to pay for it. This was shocking, especially since the damage was likely already there, but we were never given a proper chance to document or contest it. The whole process felt disorganized and misleading. I would not rent from them again.

Report
Farah Talbi
Farah Talbi
1 review

Arnaque

Affreuse expérience J rendu la voiture à 5h30 du matin il y avais personne pour la réception 7 jours après on me débite 1582 euro et ils me disent J cabossée la voiture même la photo que on l’envoi elle est flou et un coup qii n même pas d’une valeur de 50 euro arnaque J prix leur voiture a l etoport de Malte

Report
Daniele Derosas

Deposito cauzionale

Deposito cauzionale Ho noleggiato un auto dal 18/06 al 22/06 versando una cauzione di 300 euro. Ad oggi non ho ancora ricevuto indietro la somma versata

Report
Natalie
Natalie
1 review

Mietwagen nicht erhalten, Geld jedoch auch nicht zurückbekommen

Es gab einige Probleme mit dem Mietwagen-Vermieter, sodass wir unseren gesamten ersten Urlaubstag am Flughafen verbringen mussten. Mietwagen haben wir letztendlich nicht erhalten und mit der Mitarbeiterin am Schalter eine Stornierung ausgemacht. Diese wird von Opodo nun nicht anerkannt, da seitens Sicily by Car nichts an Opodo weitergeleitet wurde. Das Geld haben wir nun also auch nicht zurückerhalten und während, aber auch noch Wochen nach dem Urlaub haben wir nur Stress. Unser Geld werden wir wohl nie wieder sehen...

Report
Giardiello
Giardiello
1 review

Veicoli più volte consegnati

Veicoli più volte consegnati internamente sporchi e con peli e prima di essere consegnate ti fanno una testa tanta per nn portare animali a bordo

Report

My transaction with this company was a traumatic experience. I was charged the outrageous amount of €1218 for a small scratch on the windshield—something I didn’t even cause.

The rental was made through booking.com , with pickup on March 25th at 12:00 from Mestre Train Station and return on March 28th at 9:30 at Marco Polo Airport. The car I requested was a Peugeot 208, but when we arrived at your company’s desk, the employee informed us that the requested car was not available, and he would provide me with a Lancia Ypsilon 1.0, which is not equivalent to the Peugeot 208. The Lancia is a far inferior car in terms of technical specifications and significantly smaller in size. The employee then suggested that I pay an additional €37.95 for full insurance coverage for the 3 days. I specifically asked if the coverage was full for the 3 days, and he assured me that the amount provided full coverage for the entire rental period. After I accepted and paid the additional insurance on the spot, the employee didn’t even accompany me to the parking to show me the vehicle, but gave us directions to go to a multistory parking garage ourselves and find the car. He asked me to sign on a tablet four times without informing me exactly what I was signing. One of these documents was the “CHECK-OUT Agreement,” without inspecting the vehicle on-site and then having me agree to the points listed in the document. The vehicle was in very poor condition, unwashed, and with numerous dents. Since the dents were so many, we focused on capturing these scratches in the video and did not capture the windsceen on the video. By return of the car they "discovered" a minor scratch on the windscreen and charged immediately my credit card with the outrageous amount of €1218

Report
Deniz yılmaz

Addebitato ingiustamente nonostante rassicurazioni – Esperienza deludente

Purtroppo la mia esperienza con Sicily by Car è stata estremamente deludente. Dopo appena 20 minuti dal ritiro del veicolo, con il motore spento e il climatizzatore acceso, la batteria si è completamente scaricata. Ci trovavamo a soli 2 km dal punto di ritiro, ed è evidente che si trattasse di un problema tecnico preesistente. Il personale, sia telefonicamente che allo sportello al momento della sostituzione del veicolo, ci aveva rassicurati sul fatto che non ci sarebbero stati costi a nostro carico, trattandosi chiaramente di un guasto non imputabile a noi. Nonostante ciò, e nonostante le nostre successive email in cui spiegavamo chiaramente la situazione, ci hanno ugualmente addebitato l’importo per l’assistenza stradale (300€), rendendoci vittime di un comportamento scorretto e ingiusto. Ho richiesto anche la documentazione tecnica dell’intervento, ma nessuna risposta concreta è arrivata. Un atteggiamento poco trasparente e irrispettoso verso il cliente. Mi trovo ora costretto a procedere per vie legali e a segnalare quanto accaduto alle autorità e alle associazioni dei consumatori. Sconsiglio vivamente questa compagnia: mancano di trasparenza, correttezza e attenzione verso il cliente.

Report
Christel de Lange

They charged the car twice and no contact with customer service…

Car rental was fine but I have been charged twice for the same car after I came back home. I have been trying to contact customer service for two weeks now but no reponse. If I call, the call is reconnected and there is no response. There is also no response to my mails. Verh disappointing and I would not recommend Sicily by car if you expect any post-rental services and it you do not want to pay twice.

Report
customer
customer
1 review

Deposit not returned

The car wasn't ready when I went to collect it. So I waited and was given a vaguely cleaned one. I paid by debit card, so needed to take out additional insurance cover. I gave the car back over a month ago and my €300 deposit hasn't been returned. No contact from them to say why and Booking.com unhelpful too.

Report
Francesco Passarelli

Esperienza negativa

Esperienza negativa. Per un ritardo dovuto alla compagnia aerea mi hanno chiesto un supplemento di 50 euro...praticamente un secondo noleggio. Assurdo...mai più Sicilybycar

Report
Daan Maes
Daan Maes
1 review

Slechtste wat ik ooit meemaakte

Zeer onvriendelijk personeel. Geen idee wat er met deze vrouw aan de hand was, maar haar glimlach had ze duidelijk thuis gelaten. De gevraagde waarborg (2200 euro!) was belachelijk en dubieus hoog in verhouding tot de wagen. Ze proberen je een verzekering aan te smeren die hoger is dan het totale bedrag om de waarborg te verlagen. Uiteraard hebben we de dit geweigerd. Ze proberen je dus al op kosten te jagen bij het begin van je vakantie. De reeds betaalde kosten wouden ze niet terugbetalen, deze zijn we dus kwijt. Een andere oplossing wou de de dame zonder glimlach niet voorzien. Gewoon wegblijven van dit bedrijf. Jammer dat 0 sterren geen optie is.

Report
Mr Andrew Urmson

Awful customer service

On arrival at the desk at Pisa Airport we were told the vehicle we had booked was not available as the previous customer had not returned it. No apology was offered at any point. We were then offered an alternative vehicle that we could use until the correct vehicle was ready later that day. This was a huge inconvenience to us as it meant having to travel back to Pisa airport later that day to change vehicles and meant we could not stick to our original plans for the day. I suspect the real reason was an overbooking in your part. When I asked if they would at least cover the cost of fuel for the first vehicle given the inconvenience the gentleman at the counter simply shook his head with a smirk. Disgusting customer service.

Report
Vincenzo Lo manto

Pessima esperienza…

Ho noleggiato a Bolzano sabato 11 luglio una y10 ibrida per 7 giorni. A prescindere che tramite il sito DoyouItaly l'avevo prenotata al prezzo di € 281 con inclusa l'estenzione dell'assicurazione, sono stato fortemente consigliato dal responsabile a fare la loro assicurazione al costo di €100. Nei fatti mi sono poi visto addebitare sulla carta di credito l'importo di € 469.81 invece € 381. A ciò debbo aggiungere che mi e' stata consegnata un' auto con km 95mila con il motore morto, piena di graffi documentabili dal foglio di consegna. Veramente indecente. Andiamo a ritirare l'auto e la troviamo con il bagagliaio non pulito del suo contenuto e con cartoni di pizza. Veramente inqualificabile. Questa mattina mentre ero alla guida mi sono accorto che il quadro segnalava il guasto ad uno stop cosa questa che ho accertato. Ho chiamato l'ufficio di Bolzano e mi e' stato risposto che capita. Ho chiesto se provvedevo a mie spese a fare verificare l'anomalia per poi ottenere il rimborso. Mi e' stato detto che questo non era possibile e avrebbero visto se a San Candido ove alloggiavo c'era una officina convenzionata con loro. Al momento non ho risposta. Ora dico se mi fanno una multa per lo stop non funzionante per colpa della loro scarsa manutenzione del veicolo ne debbo rispondere io?Quello che mi dispiace e' che si tratta di un autonoleggio con sede nella mia citta' di origine, Palermo. In tanti anni che noleggio auto per le vacanze o viaggi mai mi era accaduta una cosa del genere. Mai piu' Sicily by Car.Pessima.

Report
Eva Eva
Eva Eva
1 review

Ho pagato pe una Peugeot 2008

Ho pagato pe una Peugeot 2008, Suv e il signore mi hanno datto una Seat che faceva rumore. Mi ha mandato a termini per cambiarla con bambina piccola e lì non mi hanno cambiato la macchina. Neanche mi ha portato nel parcheggio, ho dovuto cercarla io 10/15 min. Oggi ho lasato la machina ma i soldi indiento no, tra 5 giorni anche se quando ho firmato mi ha detto che mi ritorna oggi. La sedia per bambina rotta pagata 60€.

Report
Olga Schöne
Olga Schöne
1 review

Absolute scammers

Absolute scammers, avoid at all costs!!! We picked up our car at the Cagliari airport (Sardinia) and were told there was no damage. Upon return, after having zero incidents, the employee somehow identified two dents which were not visible by eye, there was no paint damage and you could only see a tiny angle in the material at certain angles, even taking pictures was pointless. We were being pressured to pay for this on the spot which we refused. The bill came a week later for 1184,98 €. I wish I was joking. We are being charged over 1000€ for damage we were completely unaware of, and which is not even visible. I simply have no words for this kind of egregious scam. I am so disappointed we didn’t see the many bad reviews on Google maps first.

Report
Filip
Filip
1 review

Don't use them. Charged for extra time. Refused communication.

We rented 2 cars at the same time, delivered at same hour. They charged, on the creditcard, extra time for one of the cars. They didn't respond to my questions via contact sheet. On telephone, it was always someone else that was responsible. At last, started complaint through the travel agency and Mastercard. After 2 months and a lot of time waisted, I finally got it back.

Report
Vincent Gravier

À fuir

À fuir. Le véhicule est tombé en panne (plus de liquide de refroidissement) et Sicily By Car estime que le véhicule était en parfait état et nous a facturé le dépannage !

Report
Aleksandr Kulesov

Cancellation of reservation without…

Cancellation of reservation without notice. Unstable company. Upon arrival at the airport, the manager at the counter informed me that my reservation was cancelled, putting me in an awkward situation. Be careful

Report

Sicily by Car FAQ

Quick answers to the questions people ask most.

Is Sicily by Car a legitimate company?

Yes, Sicily by Car is a legitimate company with numerous verified customer reviews and an overall high rating. Many customers have praised the clean vehicles, friendly service, and efficient check-in and check-out processes.

Is Sicily by Car a scam?

No, Sicily by Car is not a scam. Customer feedback indicates that while there are occasional complaints, the majority of reviews are positive, highlighting reliable service and good vehicle conditions.

What services does Sicily by Car offer?

Sicily by Car offers vehicle rental services, including a variety of car models suitable for different needs. Customers have reported quick service and the availability of clean, well-maintained vehicles.

What payment methods does Sicily by Car accept?

Sicily by Car primarily accepts credit cards for rentals. Some customers have noted issues when using debit cards, which may incur additional fees at pick-up.

All 5 questions →

How can I contact customer support for Sicily by Car?

You can contact Sicily by Car's customer support through their website or at the rental locations. Many reviews mention friendly and helpful staff ready to assist with inquiries.

Alternatives to Sicily by Car

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.