Skip to main content
Tortuga Rum Cakes logo

Tortuga Rum Cakes reviews & trust report

Tortuga Rum Cakes is a well-established brand known for its premium rum cakes and gourmet products, originating from the Caribbean. The company specializes in creating a variety of rum-infused cakes, including their original Caribbean Rum Cake and seasonal offerings such as eggnog bourbon cakes. Tortuga Rum Cakes also provides complementary gourmet items like sauces and coffee, catering to a diverse customer base that includes tourists, gift shoppers, and rum enthusiasts. The company's products are widely available across the Caribbean, with a strong presence in major air and cruise ports, hotels, and gift shops. Tortuga Rum Cakes is committed to innovation, continually introducing new flavors and product combinations to enhance consumer experience. With an emphasis on quality and freshness, Tortuga aims to maintain its reputation as a leader in the specialty and liquor cakes market.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview578 customer reviews

Tortuga Rum Cakes has a positive customer experience.

Tortuga Rum Cakes enjoys a strong reputation among consumers, with many praising the deliciousness and quality of their cakes. Reviewers frequently describe the cakes as "addictive," "moist," and "the best ever," making them a popular choice for gifts, especially during the holidays.

Read full summary

Customers appreciate the economical prices and often commend the excellent service they receive. However, there are notable complaints regarding order fulfillment, with some individuals reporting issues such as receiving incorrect quantities or being dissatisfied with the product's quality, including claims of a lack of rum flavor. Additionally, a few customers express disappointment over the size of the cakes, feeling embarrassed when gifting them.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.7/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 93% happy · 5% unhappy

Best for

  • Delivery
  • Fast & efficient
  • Customer service

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Pricing
  • Shipping
578 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.7
100%
4.7 / 5 overall
578 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Mar 2023.

Last 3 months
2.5
12-month avg
2.5
All-time
4.7
Category avg
4.1
1.02.03.04.05.0Feb 23Mar 23Category avg 4.1Feb 23: 1.0 from 1 reviewMar 23: 4.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Feb 231.01
Mar 234.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 464 positive reviews

  • Delivery12%
    56 mentions
  • Fast & efficient7%
    31 mentions
  • Customer service6%
    29 mentions
  • Quality5%
    25 mentions
“These Delicious Cakes”
On “Delivery” · Oct 6, 2020

Top complaintsof 26 negative reviews

  • Customer service31%
    8 mentions
  • Pricing19%
    5 mentions
  • Shipping15%
    4 mentions
  • Payment issues12%
    3 mentions
“Beware, customer service will not be able to help”
On “Customer service” · Feb 14, 2023

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Specialty Foods.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Tortuga Rum Cakes logo
Tortuga Rum Cakes
4.7 out of 5 (good)578
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.4 out of 5 (good)100
2.0 out of 5 (poor)72
4.7 out of 5 (good)51

Bottom line: Tortuga Rum Cakes is #1 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On service, Copenhagen Coffee Dealers scores higher (4.9 vs 4.2).

Reviews

500 reviews of Tortuga Rum Cakes. Filter by what matters to you.

4.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (578)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Bert
Bert
1 review
Featured

Beware - Tortuga Rum Cakes May Not Deliver What You Paid For

I made an online order last December for 2 Provenance 6-Packs. I only received 1. I have called multiple times and have not been able to get a refund or get the product I paid for. Beware, customer service will not be able to help. They don't return your calls. Even though the cakes are very good, I will not buy from their online store again.

Report
Theresa Lord
Theresa Lord
1 review

Definitely not REAL rum cake!!!

This cake is so bad, no rum taste a weird chemical aftertaste. All the fruit is on the outside not even mixed in right. It’s nothing like it use to be and a embarrassment to any Caribbean island selling it! People buying this must have never made a cake in their lives if they actually like it! Thank God I’m Bajan and can make the real thing or I’d be crying now, I’ve had Irish butter rum cake that tasted 100 times better than this.

Report
Peggy Grandel Muraco

Sent it as a gift and was embarrassed at the size

So disappointed an embarrassed with the size. I bought and sent it to my son for his birthday since I can't be with him due to the stay at home order. In the meantime my daughter purchased one for herself. The cost was almost $30 for a cake that is so small it was embarrassing to send. I was shocked when I heard how small it was for that price. I entered in a date closer to his birthday of April 28 but they sent it immediately which was fine but not what I wanted. When I went to the site and saw the boxes all the cakes look much bigger. I bought the 16 oz size and was embarrassed when I heard how small it was. Thirty dollars was definitely not worth to pay for the price of that cake I don't care how good it is supposed to taste. I wouldn't buy from there again. I don't feel that size is worth the price.

Report
PB
PB
1 review

Never received the order

Never received the order, and shipping is bloody expensive.

Report
Michael O.
Michael O.
1 review

great cakes

great cakes. bad business people. order mixed up and they would not make me whole during christmas. I used to order cakes for family and friends every christmas. last time i did this, some friends got the wrong cakes.no explanation or cure from tortuga. i'm done with them.

Report
NYDIA PECORARO

terrible costumer service

terrible costumer service

Report
ERIC HOUSE
ERIC HOUSE
1 review

Taste from the orange cake was a…

Taste from the orange cake was a disappointed!

Report
shawn m.
shawn m.
1 review

Poor customer service

I purchased several rum cakes and I was shipped items with close expiration dates. I contacted customer service and was basically given an "oh well" answer...….I haven't ordered since. I've since started Black Beard's instead due to the lack of concern and inability to address the issue.

Report
Rebecca Whopperer

we (5 of us) have ordered from u for…

we (5 of us) have ordered from u for YEARS! and 3 christmases ago all our rum cakes were moldy. i did everything u told me to do-i sent u pics, i sent u copies of the receipts. i offered to sent the cakes back to u & u ignored the whole problem. i never heard a word from u. this problem happened to all 5 of us. since then none of us order from u.

Report
BRIAN MEGIBOW

I was charged too much for my order

I was charged too much for my order. I called and left a message. I also sent an email. The response I received advised that that “the company could enter the order for me” The same order that was already placed, overcharged, partially shipped.. I called two more times pverthe nest few weeks. and finally spoke with someone. She took my contact information for someone to call me: which never happened.

Report
EDWARD QUESADA

Sometimes the cake has no rum in it

Sometimes the cake has no rum in it. Quality Control is lacking.

Report
LEWIS ADAMS
LEWIS ADAMS
1 review

Never received my order

Never received my order. they said they couldn't help me.

Report
GILES SCHNIERLE

Very expensive and very disappointing

Very expensive. Flavor weak. Texture too light. About what you would expect in a bundt cake from a local grocery store selling for $7.00 for an 8" cake. A poor advertisement for rum. I wouldn't buy another Tortuga and I certainly wouldn't recommend it to my friends.

Report
Marion H Dudek

Not to our liking.

I ordered these cakes about 2 years ago. They were dry and basically never got eaten after the first slice. Would not order again.

Report
Barry hobbs
Barry hobbs
1 review

Your product over rated and over priced…

Your product over rated and over priced . Your company needs to access quantity with price . Not enough product for price.

Report
DONNA K.
DONNA K.
1 review

I ordered 2 cakes as gifts a few years…

I ordered 2 cakes as gifts a few years ago and one was squashed and in crumbs. After contacting their customer's service, I thought they were sending a replacement, but they wanted photos and as I had already given it as a gift to an elderly lady who couldn't send me a photo, this was impossible. I would never recommend doing business with this company plus weeks later, I was hit with a hefty customs and duty bill for the crummy cakes!

Report
Rhoushelle Bozeman

Too many difficulties w/ order..

Too many difficulties w/ order... customer is poor... not interested in rectifying the problem. If like I didn’t matter whether my order was big or small. I no longer will frequent the website or order any items and share the poor and inaccurate service w/ the entire high school staff and districts I serve. It’s too bad because you have a very good product. But the product was dwarfed by the negative customer service.

Report
Deborah Landy

Will never order from them again

Will never order from them again. Product was never delivered. Contacted customer service (no help at all). I was told to contact the delivery company. I'm pretty much out of $40.00. When you have a company that is not willing to rectify a situation and want you to do the leg work to find out what happened to their product, they are not worth dealing with....

Report

Alternatives to Tortuga Rum Cakes

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.