Skip to main content
Sicily by Car logo

Sicily by Car reviews & trust report

Sicily by Car is a vehicle transportation company specializing in car rental services across Sicily, Italy. The company offers a diverse range of vehicles to meet the needs of tourists and locals alike, providing options for various budgets and preferences. Customers can conveniently book their desired vehicles through the company’s website, www.sicilybycar.it, ensuring a seamless rental experience. Targeting travelers exploring the beautiful landscapes of Sicily, Sicily by Car aims to facilitate easy mobility for individuals, families, and groups. The company is committed to providing reliable transportation solutions, enabling customers to discover Sicily’s attractions at their own pace. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Sicily by Car strives to deliver a straightforward and user-friendly car rental process.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Sicily by Car has a positive customer experience.

Sicily by Car receives predominantly positive feedback, with many customers praising the cleanliness and quality of the vehicles, as well as the efficiency of the check-in and check-out processes. Reviewers frequently highlight the friendly and professional staff, noting quick service and helpfulness during their rentals.

Read full summary

However, some customers express frustration regarding the requirement for a credit card for deposits, which led to complications for those with debit cards. Additionally, there are complaints about unexpected fees, such as charges for tire damage that were not clearly communicated upfront. Despite these issues, the overall sentiment remains favorable, with many recommending the service for its reliability and good vehicle condition. Overall, Sicily by Car is viewed positively by the majority of its customers.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
2 of 2 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.4/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 84% happy · 11% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Returns
  • Charges
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.4
100%
4.4 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
4.4
12-month avg
4.4
All-time
4.4
Category avg
3.8
1.02.03.04.05.0Jun 25Jul 25Category avg 3.8Jun 25: 4.5 from 242 reviewsJul 25: 4.4 from 758 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Jun 254.5242
Jul 254.4758

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 419 positive reviews

  • Customer service11%
    48 mentions
  • Fast & efficient11%
    47 mentions
  • Easy to use9%
    36 mentions
  • Friendly staff6%
    26 mentions
“Almost new car”
On “Customer service” · Jul 18, 2025

Top complaintsof 57 negative reviews

  • Payment issues25%
    14 mentions
  • Returns19%
    11 mentions
  • Charges16%
    9 mentions
  • Customer service16%
    9 mentions
“We burst a tyre on the motorway due to”
On “Payment issues” · Jul 18, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vehicles & Transportation.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Sicily by Car logo
Sicily by Car
4.4 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,999
4.5 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.7 out of 5 (good)1,000

Bottom line: Sicily by Car is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On delivery, MSP - Motorcycle Spare Parts scores higher (4.7 vs 3.1).

Reviews

500 reviews of Sicily by Car. Filter by what matters to you.

4.4ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
peter Sikow
peter Sikow
1 review

The car MG was total shit

The car MG was total shit. Navigator was below standard, so bad that used my phone. Worst thing was the motor or power line, in hilly or mountainous roads this MG was useless, motor did not know whether to use ev or gasoline motors and results was high rounds, lot of voice and no power. Terrible, never again. And I booked Cupra which you changed. Expect compensation!!!!

Report
Torben
Torben
1 review

Snydt med bilmærke og stand

Snydt med bilmærke og stand

Report
Anders Borup
Anders Borup
1 review

Worst car rental ever tried

Airport center sent us 1 km away to other service center, and service center sent us back to airport. Airport center would not accept credit card for car we already paid for and service was completely ignorant and following stupid misunderstanding of rules. Never experienced this with Europecar, Sixt, Avis or other known rentals. DO NOT USE, JUST PAY FOR THE KNOWN BRANDS. Ended up paying 70 euro extra and fill a ton of forms for nothing.

Report
Tim S
Tim S
1 review

They ripped me off

They ripped me off. I was late 2 hour and they charged me double the charge of daily rate for this 2 hou delay

Report
Maura Barardo

Pessimo servizio

sono(ero) una cliente abituale e noleggio regolarmente in aeroporto più volte l'anno. L ultima volta mi è stata assegnata una Fiat Panda in condizioni inaccettabili: aria condizionata non funzionante, radio inutilizzabile , spia manutenzione accesa. Sono rimasta molto delusa, soprattutto dopo aver avvisato il personale e mandato un reclamo sul format aziendale senza ricevere risposta. Pessimo servizio .

Report
Ivanoiu  Relu
Ivanoiu Relu
1 review

I pay 450

I booked for 280 euro, I paid 450 and 300 as a guarante

Report
Lucia.tatita Tatita

Mai più con loro

Mai più con loro. Prenoto su internet arrivo all’aeroporto di Olbia e non mi danno l’auto. Assolutamente sconsigliato

Report
Pa Wel
Pa Wel
1 review

In Catania airport, hostile and unpleasant staff! Fire this girl on the spot!

In Catania airport we booked car: Compact: Cupra Born or similar, CDAE/CDAE 5 seats, 4 doors, Air Conditioning, Automatic , Electric At the desk there was very hostile and unpleasant girl shouting at us that we didn't booked Cupra, after an argument her colleague also started shouting at us. At the we as family of four with our baggage was given small citroen! She told us that they dont have car we booked, but after we went to collection point there was at least two cupra born parked there! The staff need to be fired for such customer service... Wont be booking or recommending this company to anyone. Will be following up with this case after the holidays.

Report
Janine van Lieshout

Oplichters

Afgelopen week een auto gehuurd in Kroatië.Tip: controleer de auto heel goed. Ook de onderkant van de bumpers. Daar zat bij ons een schade welke niet te zien was op t filmpje dat ik gemaakt had. Bij het ophalen van de auto wordt netjes heel de auto nagelopen behalve de onderkant van de bumpers. Bij het inleveren werd dat als eerste gedaan. Je krijgt meteen t gevoel dat je erin geluisd wordt. Ze wisten dat ik een verzekering elders had afgesloten. Er wordt ook gelijk een schadebedrag genoemd . Maar je hebt zelf geen bewijs dus helaas betalen. Enorme domper van je vakantie. Dus of je auto heel goed controleren inclusief onderkant maar beter nog; GEEN zaken met ze doen : OPLICHTERS.

Report
Michela P
Michela P
1 review

Esperienza pessima

Esperienza pessima. Abbiamo atteso un'ora per ritirare una macchina già prenotata e pagata. Il personale allo sportello è assolutamente incompetente e cafone, e hanno insistito per prendere 300€ di caparra nonostante il contratto indicasse 100€ dato che abbiamo pagato l'assicurazione più completa. Abbiamo assistito a due signore che hanno quasi perso il volo per colpa dell'incompetenza del personale. Ti danno risposte arroganti e inconcludenti, finché per sfinimento non acconsenti a quello che vogliono loro. In più la macchina ci è stata consegnata sporca.

Report
Dirk Apers
Dirk Apers
1 review

The most hostile “customer service” I’ve encountered in years

I prepaid a one-week rental with SicilyByCar and arrived with every document in hand at Bologna airport, only to be stone-walled at every turn: Debit-vs-credit card standoff – The agent refused my Mastercard because it’s technically a debit card, even though it has never been rejected elsewhere and the booking site never flagged this as an issue. No alternative payment accepted – When I offered my travel companion’s credit card for the security hold, I was told that would require adding him as a driver—“not possible”. I then proposed paying the €200 deposit outright in cash or by card. Also “not possible”. Zero flexibility—even for a day – I offered to return the next morning with a different credit card. They still refused, claiming they wouldn’t hold the vehicle despite my having already paid for the full week. Needlessly hostile tone – Every suggestion (paying extra fees, changing the booking, fetching another card) was met with curt, dismissive replies. No effort to find a solution—just “computer says no.” Fortunately, Booking.com intervened and cancelled the reservation, so at least I recovered my money. But I lost valuable holiday hours scrambling for a replacement car. Bottom line: If you value time, courtesy or the slightest trace of flexibility, avoid SicilyByCar entirely. There are plenty of rental firms in Italy that still understand the meaning of customer service.

Report
Dario Mastrogiacomo

Non mi è piaciuto proprio nulla

Non mi è piaciuto proprio nulla. Viaggio spesso e spesso noleggio auto. Ho noleggiato 3 volte con questa compagnia e tutte le volte qualcosa non è andato bene. non la consiglio.

Report
Kačka Anna Nádvorníková

Horrible

Horrible. They refused to give us a car, just because se only had debit card and not credit. They stole from us almost 200€.

Report
SUCIU ALEXANDRU

I was obliged to wash my car at…

I was obliged to wash my car at drop-off. It is not normal to clean the car by yourself. This should have been included in the rental price, which was high enough. I was almost to lose my flight because of this

Report
Dávid Pej
Dávid Pej
1 review

Deposit withholding !!!!!!!!!!!!

I rented a car from Sicily by Car and returned it in perfect condition, on time, and fully refueled. Despite this, €80, 61 was withheld from my deposit without any explanation or documentation. I contacted customer service multiple times, but received no response at all. This lack of transparency and communication is unacceptable. I was forced to escalate the issue through the European Consumer Centre and my bank. I do not recommend this company, and I advise others to be extremely cautious when renting from them.

Report
Teo Garny
Teo Garny
1 review

Sicily by car est une agence de voleur

Sicily by car est une agence de voleur, pour commencer 3h à attendre mais ce n’est pas grave ! Étant particulièrement minutieux j’ai éplucher le contrat avant d’arriver à l’agence, j’avais deux carte à mon nom une débit une crédit, la personne au guichet m’as dit de payer 200€ (sur ma caution) et 97€ de plus sur le prix de location car ma carte de crédit n’étais pas « conforme », je lui donne donc mon autre carte, carte de débit mais nan ça ne vas pas non plus , cette fois si parce que elle est « française » donc bloqué à l’aéroport 300€ à payer en plus et pourtant la caution a bien été retiré de mon compte il n’y as pas eu de problème pour cela ! Pour finir ! 1 mois et 3 semaines exactement pour être rembourser, évitez cette agence ce sont de véritable voleur !

Report
Vladimir
Vladimir
1 review

All went well until they mysteriously…

All went well until they mysteriously decided to keep my deposit. I have the certificate stating everything went well, but then somehow they disputed and mentioned they had wired the money. I'm still baffled how you can get away with such predatory commercial practices in 2025. Loved the island though. but don't get ever close to this company.

Report
Lorenzo Gómez

Nada recomendable

El vehículo presentaba un olor desagradable y un interior notablemente sucio. El embrague no funcionaba correctamente y emitía un ruido inusual que generaba inseguridad durante la conducción. La atención recibida en el mostrador fue deficiente. Como usuario habitual de servicios de alquiler de vehículos, considero esta experiencia como la peor hasta la fecha. No volveré a utilizar su empresa ni la recomendaré.

Report
Vivien
Vivien
1 review

Arnaque

En juin 2025 , j’ai réservé et payé en avance pour une location de voiture à travers EasyJet qui a eu un problème informatique au moment de réservation du coup nous avons au un erreur de prénom dans la réservation. Au moment de la prise du véhicule, l’agence de location nous a informé qu’on n’aura pas la voiture. Pas de proposition de solution. EasyJet nous demande de régler et insister auprès de Sicilybycar bay car mais il refusait complètement et il nous ont remercié pour le payement! Au final, EasyJet jette la faute soit sur moi, soit sur l’agence de location et l’agence de location jette la faute sur EasyJet qui a tenté de discuter avec eux. Au final, j’ai payé pour un service que je n’ai pas eu et tout le monde s’est mis plein les poches. On m’a dit « c’est la vie madame! Je suis en rage car on m’a proposé aucune solution!!!!!

Report
BELSKY ZIV
BELSKY ZIV
1 review

misleading large car description

We rented a car for 5 adults for 2 weeks in Italy indirectly (through another website). We paid for a Group U (9 person) car, Mercedes Vito on the website. and arrived to find a basic model Ford Transit 2.0 with unmovable, uncomfortable seats. We ended up taking a Skoda station instead, which was much smaller (and cheaper) but had more comfortable seats, but Sicily by Car insisted they can't reimburse us for the difference; it turns out they could but chose not to. So we basically overpaid for the car we took. Be careful about the car you're promised to get!

Report

Sicily by Car FAQ

Quick answers to the questions people ask most.

Is Sicily by Car a legitimate company?

Yes, Sicily by Car is a legitimate company with numerous verified customer reviews and an overall high rating. Many customers have praised the clean vehicles, friendly service, and efficient check-in and check-out processes.

Is Sicily by Car a scam?

No, Sicily by Car is not a scam. Customer feedback indicates that while there are occasional complaints, the majority of reviews are positive, highlighting reliable service and good vehicle conditions.

What services does Sicily by Car offer?

Sicily by Car offers vehicle rental services, including a variety of car models suitable for different needs. Customers have reported quick service and the availability of clean, well-maintained vehicles.

What payment methods does Sicily by Car accept?

Sicily by Car primarily accepts credit cards for rentals. Some customers have noted issues when using debit cards, which may incur additional fees at pick-up.

All 5 questions →

How can I contact customer support for Sicily by Car?

You can contact Sicily by Car's customer support through their website or at the rental locations. Many reviews mention friendly and helpful staff ready to assist with inquiries.

Alternatives to Sicily by Car

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.