Skip to main content
My Rental Homes logo

My Rental Homes reviews & trust report

My Rental Homes is a comprehensive online platform specializing in the rental of villas, apartments, and holiday homes across popular destinations in the Mediterranean and beyond. The company offers a diverse catalog of over 800 properties, catering to travelers looking for luxurious accommodations by the sea and in ski regions. Customers can explore a wide range of options, including prestigious villas in Italy, Greece, Spain, and Morocco, designed to meet various preferences and budgets. Targeting vacationers and holidaymakers, My Rental Homes provides an intuitive search experience, allowing users to filter properties by location, type, and amenities. By connecting renters with distinctive homes in sought-after destinations, the company aims to enhance the travel experience for individuals and families seeking memorable stays in exclusive locales.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview182 customer reviews

My Rental Homes has a positive customer experience.

Reviewers consistently praise My Rental Homes for their exceptional service and the quality of their properties. Many highlight the great locations and stunning views of the villas, with comments about the cleanliness and spaciousness of the accommodations.

Read full summary

Customers appreciate the quick response times and helpful staff, who assist with everything from check-in to local recommendations. However, a few reviews mention issues such as cramped indoor spaces and the misleading labeling of some properties as "villas" when they are actually large apartments. Additionally, there are suggestions for improvements, like the need for more towels and cleaning of outdoor furniture. Overall, the majority of feedback reflects a highly positive experience, making My Rental Homes a recommended choice for travelers.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.8/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 97% happy · 2% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
-3%
Declining vs the 6 months before · was 4.9

Best for

  • Helpful support
  • Customer service
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Defective product
182 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.8
100%
4.8 / 5 overall
182 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jan 2024.

Last 3 months
5.0▲ 0.3
12-month avg
4.8
All-time
4.8
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Mar 23AprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJan 24Category avg 4.0Mar 23: 5.0 from 1 reviewApr 23: 5.0 from 3 reviewsMay 23: 4.6 from 8 reviewsJun 23: 4.9 from 15 reviewsJul 23: 4.9 from 10 reviewsAug 23: 4.7 from 9 reviewsSep 23: 4.8 from 15 reviewsOct 23: 4.5 from 8 reviewsNov 23: 5.0 from 2 reviewsDec 23: 5.0 from 1 reviewJan 24: 5.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Mar 235.01
Apr 235.03
May 234.68
Jun 234.915
Jul 234.910
Aug 234.79
Sep 234.815
Oct 234.58
Nov 235.02
Dec 235.01
Jan 245.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 182 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 176 positive reviews

  • Helpful support22%
    38 mentions
  • Customer service13%
    23 mentions
  • Easy to use13%
    23 mentions
  • Fast & efficient7%
    13 mentions
“They were helpful in explaining issues and they made sure we were fully informed about the property and the local whe...”
On “Helpful support” · Jan 8, 2024

Top complaintsof 4 negative reviews

  • Defective product50%
    2 mentions
“The grounds of the villa are well maintained, pretty and spacious and the pool is a decent size, but unheated”
On “Defective product” · Oct 22, 2023

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
My Rental Homes logo
My Rental Homes
4.8 out of 5 (good)182
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: My Rental Homes is #3 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On delivery, Audley Travel scores higher (5.0 vs 4.5).

Reviews

182 reviews of My Rental Homes. Filter by what matters to you.

4.8ⓘ

Customer reviews (182)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Mr Cowley
Mr Cowley
1 review

Lovely spacious villa complex in great…

Lovely spacious villa complex in great location, Professionally run, clean and welcoming, would definitely recommend.

Report
Yous
Yous
1 review

Absolument parfait

Absolument parfait La maison en tout point conforme à la description Je recommande sans hésiter

Report
Ed S
Ed S
1 review

Casa Dorothea was clean and well…

Casa Dorothea was clean and well equipped, with a good sized swimming pool and very helpful owner.

Report
Sean
Sean
1 review

Perfect

Jacaranda house is in a beautiful location, has a terrific layout and furnishings, is exceptionally clean, and owners are very responsive. We loved ghe private garden and two balconies (one in each upstairs bedroom). We highly recommend.

Report
Mark
Mark
1 review

To the point

To the point and pragmatic. Good arrival information.

Report
Stacey
Stacey
1 review

Sorrento apartment

Nice place to stay. Good location.

Report
Uwe H.
Uwe H.
1 review

The view of this home was stunning

The view of this home was stunning. Since your so high up on the mountain you can always see half of Santorini including the Airport. The house was clean and in good conditions. The night before you had a menu of different options for breakfast, and they would set the table for you and deliver you breakfast every day. The bedrooms in this house were all separate, which was nice because you had lots of privacy. You had 2 kitchens which was also very convenient. The Villa manage Dimitris did an awesome job.

Report
Nicole
Nicole
1 review

Magical views and comfort Casa Annalu

We loved Casa Annalu and it was magical place for our family of 4 which includes 2 young adult girls. The views were unbeatable and we spent a lot of time on the large balcony. The apartment was so big, spacious, super clean and great air con. Having a washing machine was a bonus. The host was very communicative and even allowed us early access to the apartment with refreshing drinks on arrival. The location is great - near the famous Franco’s Bar, a few steps to a main bus stop to take you along the coast and a deli nearby. There are a few hundred steps to get down to the beach but that is for most places in Positano that have great views! We didn’t find the traffic noise an issue at all. We loved Casa Annalu and it made our stay in Positano even more special and would stay again.

Report
LP
LP
1 review

Thoroughly unpleasant stay

Thoroughly unpleasant stay that doesn't even get close to the level of service that you'd expect from the price. Started with the person responsible for facilitating check-in hanging up on my face. There was a broken tile int he bathroom with some sharp shards sticking out of the wall. Property was somewhat dirty and there was still signs of trash in the kitchen. Glasses in the closet, dirty dishes in the cabinets and dishwasher not emptied. Consistent smell of gas from the stove. Rock hard mattresses. Diluted shower gels and no shampoos. No functioning entry gate remote. Lastly, the crib we had asked for was not installed and no one cared to help (also, didn't have bedsheets). Property managers were not apologetic at all for this very long list of issues and were completely uninterested in making amendments (not a surprise given the state the property was in!). AVOID AT ALL COSTS!

Report
Ed schwarz
Ed schwarz
1 review

Need better kitchen items and and a…

Need better kitchen items and and a real forno

Report
Verity
Verity
1 review

My Rental Homes - Fantastic!! Villa & Balearic Villas - Terrible!!

We booked a villa for 2 weeks through My Rental Homes this June in Port de Pollensa in Majorca with Guido at My Rental Homes. My Rental Homes & Guido were fantastic throughout the whole process but unfortunately our holiday was pretty disastrous due to our experience at the villa & with Balearic Villas who managed the villa during our stay. The villa was based in Gotmar & called Villa Cub 1. It was a great location & had impressive views & the villa itself had plenty of amazing features, but we were unable to appreciate it much due to a number of major issues. Firstly, there was major building work going on directly in front of the villa and next door which both completely overlooked the pool area & villa with workmen able to see directly into most bathrooms and producing excessively loud & unbearable noise for most of the day from 8am till 6pm & on Saturdays. They were using pneumatic breakers, jackhammers & diggers scrapping up concrete plus many other noisy machineries throughout most of the day, so it was impossible to be able to relax in any of the outdoor areas in the villa. It was so load at times we couldn't hear each other talk & the concrete scrapping was like the sound of fingernails down a blackboard. We were informed prior to our stay of the building work by Balearic but it was massively downplayed & we were told there was restrictions on noise levels & what tools could be used. Secondly when we arrived at the villa the entrance gate to the villa was in a terrible state, broken & unlockable & one of the main entrances to the villa was broken & a nightmare to lock. We learnt from our oversharing Rep that they were aware of these faults & other clients had complained previous, but they had just left them unfixed & the entrance door was never fixed during our whole 2 week stay & at times we were unable to secure the property at all. The management company, Balearic Villas came across as professional & helpful to begin with but over our stay & interaction with them, making complaints about the noise etc we realised they were very much the opposite, full of excuses, untrustworthy, dishonest & false. Guido handled the whole situation brilliantly, but Balearic Villas were very much the opposite. Guido compensated us, Balearic Villas did very little & like I said were just full of excuses and untrustworthy. I very much recommend My Rental Villas but would avoid booking any villas that are managed by Balearic Villas.

Report
Susan
Susan
1 review

Wonderful place!

Wonderful place!

Report
John
John
1 review

Great spot for our family

Great spot for our family! The view of Isola Bella is indeed as beautiful as it looks. Just (steep!) steps down to the beach for a great day kayaking and swimming around the island and exploring. Easy to get up to town on the funicular; or a good -hot- walk up the stairs, making you deserving of another gelato! The space is a little tight - but we were 8 people and we managed. It was the perfect spot for our family and I'd highly recommend it!

Report
Denver Customer

Rental home in Sicily was amazing

Rental home in Sicily was amazing! The emails in advance of our trip were not as clear as they could be.

Report
PD
PD
1 review

Villa Carteni stay- July 2022

We stayed at Villa Carteni for 10 days in July 2022. The outdoor setting of the villa is beautiful and a lot of the pictures that are on the websites do not do it justice. The garden is very well kept, with a gardener visiting during our stay. The flowers and butterflies that inhabit the grounds are gorgeous and it makes for a beautiful setting while you’re are relaxing at the villa. The pool was well maintained and a descent size. The area where you sunbath and chillout is a nice area where you can choose to bask in the sun overlooking the sea or cool down in the shade. We really enjoyed the grounds. The villa itself is excellent for large groups as it has three self-contained apartments which is ideal for getting together whilst also having your own space. The top and middle apartments are spacious and have air conditioning which is super. We also used the washing machine to freshen things up and the clothes dried in no time outside. The bottom apartment wasn’t quite as good as it doesn’t have aircon but fans are available. It is more of an old style area and did smell old too. Things that the villa could do with are more mirrors and places for someone to sit and dry their hair and do makeup. It did not have a safety deposit box which we worried about at first but it is situated within people’s own homes, so it didn’t pose as a problem but we would have had peace of mind if it had had one. The villa does have locked gates and doors around the property. The neighbours were very welcoming and made sure that we knew what was happening in the area ( road closures/ nights on in the town). The little town centre is a few minutes walk down a steep hill but has a lovely restaurant ‘a Cammarella’ , which do take aways and there was a good burger place and ice cream/ crepe shop, which was a great hit with the kids. There is also a wee supermarket to get your shopping from. On the downside, the roads up to the villa are very, very narrow and it can be tricky to drive to, especially at night. If hiring a car, be careful what size of car you are taking. The company ‘My Rental Homes Italy’ were super throughout our stay, especially Chiara who looked after us. Nothing was a bother for her, from finding us somewhere to grab food when we arrived in late from our flight to organising maintenance at the villa or booking a yacht to take us a tour of Capri.

Report
Pedro
Pedro
1 review

Great home

Great home, great treatment and service from Andreas. Incredible views.

Report
Jessica
Jessica
1 review

Loved Luanda and Fulvio

We stayed at Villa Luanda and found the property to be nearly perfect! The service of Fulvio including as our vip host was top notch and exceeded our expectations. Although there was construction ongoing we were not overly bothered by it. Loved our stay and we will definitely look at this portfolio again when booking the next trip to Ibiza or anywhere served by My Rental Homes.

Report
Jamil Karriem

Incredible experience

Incredible experience. Company goes above and beyond!

Report
Gail
Gail
1 review

Spectacular views

Newly renovated, well appointed home with spectacular views. Impeccable clean. Quiet area. Very close to Massa Lubrenese and Sorrento but NOT walking. I'd recommend renting a car. Loved this house.

Report
ANGHARAD LITTLE

A* would highly recommend!

A* would highly recommend!

Report

Alternatives to My Rental Homes

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.