Skip to main content
Effy Jewelry logo

Effy Jewelry reviews & trust report

Effy Jewelry is a U.S.-based jewelry manufacturer and retailer, specializing in handcrafted pieces that blend artistic design with quality craftsmanship. With over three decades of experience, the company offers a diverse range of jewelry, including rings, necklaces, and bracelets, catering to customers seeking unique and meaningful gifts for various occasions. The brand is particularly popular among individuals looking to express their sentiments through jewelry, whether for special occasions like Valentine's Day or for everyday wear. Effy Jewelry emphasizes the importance of family and community in its operations, ensuring that each piece reflects a commitment to creativity and excellence. Customers can explore a variety of collections, including new arrivals and themed gift guides, on their website at www.effyjewelry.com.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview108 customer reviews

Effy Jewelry has a positive customer experience.

Effy Jewelry receives a mix of praise and criticism from its customers. Many reviewers appreciate the beautiful selection of rings and the helpfulness of staff like Conquela, who is frequently mentioned for her exceptional service.

Read full summary

Positive experiences highlight the quality of the jewelry and prompt customer service responses, with some customers noting successful resolutions to their issues. However, a significant number of complaints focus on product quality, with several consumers reporting stones falling off rings shortly after purchase. Additionally, frustrations arise from poor customer service experiences, including unresponsive communication and difficulties in processing returns. Overall, while Effy Jewelry has its advocates, the concerns regarding product durability and customer support cannot be overlooked.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
3.6/ 5
Mostly positive
Polarized: 63% happy · 34% unhappy
Momentum · 6 months
-15%
Declining vs the 6 months before · was 3.8

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Helpful support
  • Quality

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Pricing
  • Returns
108 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
3.6
100%
3.6 / 5 overall
108 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Aug 2025.

Last 3 months
2.7▼ 1.0
12-month avg
3.6
All-time
3.6
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Sep 24OctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJulAug 25Category avg 4.0Sep 24: 3.8 from 24 reviewsOct 24: 3.0 from 10 reviewsNov 24: 3.5 from 6 reviewsDec 24: 4.1 from 7 reviewsJan 25: 2.8 from 5 reviewsFeb 25: 4.8 from 13 reviewsMar 25: 4.2 from 6 reviewsApr 25: 3.7 from 7 reviewsMay 25: 3.5 from 10 reviewsJun 25: 3.2 from 12 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewAug 25: 2.1 from 7 reviews
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Sep 243.824
Oct 243.010
Nov 243.56
Dec 244.17
Jan 252.85
Feb 254.813
Mar 254.26
Apr 253.77
May 253.510
Jun 253.212
Jul 251.01
Aug 252.17

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 108 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 68 positive reviews

  • Customer service34%
    23 mentions
  • Helpful support21%
    14 mentions
  • Quality18%
    12 mentions
  • Website & app15%
    10 mentions
“I had an issue with my ring and their customer service was amazing”
On “Customer service” · Aug 22, 2025

Top complaintsof 37 negative reviews

  • Customer service41%
    15 mentions
  • Pricing32%
    12 mentions
  • Returns30%
    11 mentions
  • Payment issues27%
    10 mentions
“Very disappointed in how this reputable company handled this transaction, very bad, I would not recommend to buy jewe...”
On “Customer service” · Aug 28, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Jewelry.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Effy Jewelry logo
Effy Jewelry
3.6 out of 5 (good)108
1.3 out of 5 (poor)1,000
2.9 out of 5 (fair)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)397
2.6 out of 5 (poor)368

Bottom line: Effy Jewelry is #2 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Red Run scores higher (4.9 vs 2.1).

Reviews

108 reviews of Effy Jewelry. Filter by what matters to you.

3.6ⓘ

Customer reviews (108)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
How CrowdTrust scores reviews

Polarized pattern: few middle ratings. 63% of recent reviews are 4–5★ and 34% are 1–2★.

carbo “trojanlife” carbo

Treated like a redheaded stepchild …

We bought a diamond tennis necklace from Ana/Andre for $17,000 onboard the Norwegian Breakaway that the associates claimed were natural diamonds. However, when we picked up the receipt readied 2 days later at the time of disembarkment, the receipt indicated that they were lab grown diamonds. Once at home the next day I contacted customer service by email and received a terse reply that the receipt indicated “lab grown diamonds” and to send the diamond necklace back if desired. There was no attempt to decrease the price of the necklace which was 50-85% overpriced. Their website states that every customer is treated like family but experience made me feel like a red headed stepchild. I will send the necklace back and NEVER do business with them. UPDATE "A FEW IMPORTANT DETAILS" WOW! Typical corporate response in taking no responsibility for the problems with this transaction. Obviously, if Effy was committed to transparency I would have received a receipt at the time of purchase and not 2 days later the night before the end of the cruise. Andrea, that is an OUTRIGHT FALSEHOOD. Andre and Ana submitted to me that they were natural diamonds and repeatedly told me that they were natural diamonds. I’m returning the necklace waiting for a full refund.

Report
Lina Fuste
Lina Fuste
1 review

Don’t let the beauty fool you

I purchased a beautiful ring from Effie in 2022 two months in one of the baguettes fell off the side another month later another baguette fell off Macy’s went ahead and repaired it for me. Fast-forward a year and the center stone falls off. They replaced it for me a year later the center stone falls off once again when I got the ring back, I noticed that the prongs that hold the center stone are really not tight. It’s almost as if they purposely do poor craftsmanship so you’ll have to spend money replacing stones from them. I sent in my ring a month ago to get repaired. I left three different voicemails for Marla (customer service supervisor) that went unanswered and two messages with the operator. After yet another message. left with the operator on Monday, I finally received an email today, Wednesday, June 4 stating that they weren’t gonna cover the repair of the stone cause it’s not part of their limited lifetime warranty. I called in. I asked to speak to a supervisor lo and behold. I finally was able to speak to Marla, who was the epitome of rude whatever happened to customer service? No apologies for the craftsmanship. No apologies for the problems and issues I’ve had with the ring just plain rude now they want $375 to replace the stone on the ring.

Report
Martin Farber

Garbage jewelery with inflated prices

Garbage jewelery with inflated prices. They claim things retail for ten times their value and are giving you 80-90% off. In reality, they never sell anything for full price and even at 80-90% off any jeweler will appraise it for less than half of what you paid. The quality also sucks. The stones are not set flush.

Report
Michel C.
Michel C.
1 review

I disatisfied of the ring missed…

I disatisfied of the ring missed diamond some of them when size repair after received look so different missed diamonds, we are traumatized and not trust ever again. i want refunds and unhappy. hey dont trust repair are thief diamonds. i have proof before picture of the ring and after picture. no more buy again if not fit dont buy to send repairs.

Report
MARION BOWDEN

I brought a ring on a cruise in March/April and was told…Bad Business

I brought a ring in March and was told to come back at the end of the cruise to get my valuation certificate but all I got was a receipt for what I paid.I was not happy and told them so.I will NEVER buy from Effy again a lot of money wasted.No answer from the company as of 9th June really care not

Report
Steve Cripps
Steve Cripps
1 review

Having purchased a $18,000 AAA…

Having purchased a $18,000 AAA Tanzanite and Diamond 14K Gold ring onboard Island Princess, I had to use the UK resizing service in Hatton Garden, London, as the ring was 4 sides to small (I know, but). The only cost was stated as being £5.00 - £10.00 insured postage which actually cost a Wapping £38:00. The service provided by the UK arm of Effy was at best extremely poor. Then 5 weeks later the ring was returned with a replacement valued postage at just £2,000 🤬. However, the size was 1.5 times larger that it should have been. Effy refused to reside for a 2nd time resulting in my having to take the ring to a competent Jewels and pay for the ring to then be reduced in size from Q1/2 to P as should have been the case originally. In contacting Effy Head Office in New York they have not only repeated their refusal to assist but point blank refused to refund either the cost of the £38 postage, but also the amount of just £54 to rectify their mistakes. So for the sake of a mere £92.00, they are happy to lose a customer who over the past 3 years has spent in excess of £40,000 with Effy. BUYER BEWARE. We have since established that Effy market ALL of their Jewellery at between 60%-80% above the True value. BUYER BEWARE. WHATCH THIS SPACE FOR PART 2 of this saga 🤬🤢🤮

Report
Kelly Forsyth

Poor service, cheap craftsmanship.

My almost 80 year old mother has just had a horrible experience with this company and their customer support. For this reason I am leaving this review. She just returned a piece for warranty for the second time in under two years. From now on, we will buy local and get it serviced locally. Myself after this will never purchase anything affiliated with this company.

Report
Ahmad
Ahmad
1 review

The worst quality ever

The worst quality ever. Every time I buy something from these products, they break after a month of use. It is not a good experience. Every time I wanted to not send something like this, but I had enough of the very poor quality of the products. I will write a comment on the site about the quality of these products.

Report
Joni
Joni
1 review

Buyer BEWARE!!

Buyer BEWARE!!! Bought a necklace (and with 2 witnesses) was guaranteed it was 14K white gold. Came home to have clasp made stronger and turns out it's STERLING SILVER!!! SO I paid way over price. Found out from another friend it happened to them also. Bought on one of the islands and not planning to return anytime soon. Spoke with NY customer service. THEY COULDN'T CARE LESS!! They said so return it at MY expense!!!

Report
Deb
Deb
1 review

Not Reliable

Sent item for repair. Never heard back. Totally unreliable.

Report
KW
KW
1 review

Be very careful of your purchases with Effy.

I was on a cruise in September 2024 on the Royal Caribbean Brillance with my youngest daughter. I had lost my husband a year prior due to his military service in Vietnam (Agent Orange). Per the ship Effy was supposed to be a wonderful place to get good prices. I wanted to get a new ring because that is what my husband would have purchased for me if he was alive. I picked out a ring and then of course they pushed additional items. One of the items was to be free because of the amount items I was purchasing. I was charged for the full amount of the item that was supposed to be free. I contacted customer service at Effy and after several emails with them I was told the manager over all Land stores (Anthony) would be contacting me. Well that never happened. I tried several times to get an answer. They really stole $630.00 from me. I even sent them copies of the Receipt after the Customer service person stated, "you were not charged for it". Don't know what kind of calculator they use. When I had the item appraised when I got home it was not even worth that much. I will never step inside one of their stores and advise others not to do so.

Report
Sean Grewan
Sean Grewan
1 review

FALS

Hi Please tell me who is going to reimburse me for the money i spent on my plane ticket as i am from Durban your invitations are very misleading especially for such a big company i used my savings to pay for this. Pathetic all of your information is misleading i will take this further. Instead of sending me a email of going with candidates how will i be reimbursed i have bought a outfit to where. I need feedback

Report
JL
JL
1 review

They sell Fake stones in cruise ships

I would have given a score of ZERO if I could. Bought a lab pink diamond ring from NCL cruise, and the sales guy didn’t provided me a certificate as promised. After we returned home, I brought the ring to a local jewellery shop because I need to adjust the size, then I was told that there is no GIA code embedded in the stone ( even lab diamond will have one if it is big). I contacted the customer service in Aug, got the reply saying that they will send the GIA cert to my address, but then waited for couple of months and after a few chases, no response anymore, it is a SCAM company. Stay away! And thanks for your reply in 24 hrs, but how can I contact anyone when your customer services never reply to my emails! I can see most of good reviews are from US, maybe customers outside US doesn’t deserve the same product quality and after service then!

Report
Brian Sherwin

Overcharged

Bought a ring for $5400 in store at Nassau. Came to ship and they were offering it for $5000. I would shop somewhere else where they are honest about pricing.

Report
Pina
Pina
1 review

Scammed

On Celebrity Summit cruise I bought a pair of earrings from Effy, paying more than I would have paid them by buying them in the store. Once I return to Italy after a few weeks I lose the screw-back of the earring of one of the two earrings, of course due to a defect. The lost screw-back of the earring is not standard than those found here in Italy. But it screws to the back of the earring. I contact the customer care several times to send me this particular type of screw-back of the earring and send me the standard one that obviously does not fit to the earring they produce Effy customer care has been ignoring me for weeks and after spending all that money my earrings are in the drawer because I can't wear them or I could lose them. Get away from Effy. Don’t buy anything on a cruise and rely on reliable and professional people I feel scammed

Report
Rainy Michaeu

I purchased a necklace from Effy and…

I purchased a necklace from Effy and when it arrived, the chain was so twisted and knotted around the the seahorse that i couldn't get it off. I worked on it for over an hour, and finally ended up having to break the chain to get it off. I replied to an email from effy asking for a review and mentioned what had happened. Instead of calling me and offering to send a new chain without charge, they called and actually wanted me to buy more from them with a 40% discount....awful customer service

Report

Betrug durch EFFY!

Betrug! Ring und Kette auf MSC Kreuzfahrtschiff Orchestra im EFFY Store gekauft. Wertgutachten über 11.445 US Dollar an Bord trotz Zusage nicht dazu erhalten. Erst nach der Reise auf mehrfache Nachfrage beim Customer Support in New York per Email zugeschickt bekommen. Die Schmuckstücke sind nach Aussage zweier unabhängiger Juweliere keine 1.000 EUR Wert. Rückgabe bei EFFY wird abgelehnt, weil ihre 30 Tage Rückgabefrist lt. Policy abgelaufen ist. Was ist mit ihrer Compliance Policy? Customer Support in New York unternimmt nichts zur Lösung. Finger weg!

Report
Elena Mocanu
Elena Mocanu
1 review

Did not receive my package

Did not receive my package

Report
Theresa Rhyne

I’m currently on Celebrity Beyond…

I’m currently on Celebrity Beyond cruise ship they are selling EFFY cheap jewelry just like Royal Caribbean. This jewelry is low end and should be sold at Walmart

Report
Luciana Gallego pineda

This store is a complete scam

This store is a complete scam. I will never make a purchase here again. I spent three days negotiating with a supervisor at the Effy store on an MSC cruise ship. From the beginning, I made it clear that I was only interested in 18k gold, not the 14k gold they usually sell. On the last night of the cruise, around 11 pm, the supervisor sold me two rings and a bracelet, assuring me they were all 18k gold with white and yellow diamonds. He claimed he was too busy to prepare the certificate at the moment and would send it to my room after they closed. The next day, which was also the last day of the cruise, I received the certificate and was shocked to find that it stated the rings were 14k gold and contained only white diamonds. There were no yellow diamonds—just some yellow gold around the stones to make them look like yellow diamonds. I immediately contacted a cruise ship supervisor, and they got in touch with the Effy store supervisor. I asked him to put everything in writing, and this is what he sent: *"I'm writing the email to make sure we are going to find a solution to exchange the gold from 14k to 18k in the ring she purchased, and that the warranty will cover anything that happens with the pieces, and that the upgrade can be done with another value that is not double the value purchased. Thank you."* I waited over two weeks for a response. They finally got back to me, only to say: *"They will contact you to get a special order to make the same ring in 18ct gold, but unfortunately, there will be a cost involved. They will try to minimize it as much as they can."* So here I am, having already paid around $20,000, and they have the audacity to ask me to pay extra. It’s been almost two months, and I haven’t received the refund after I sent the items back the day after discovering the scam. This is for something sold to me as 18k gold and yellow diamonds that turned out to be 14k gold and white diamonds. Save your money and avoid these scammers at all costs.

Report

Alternatives to Effy Jewelry

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.