Sports Integrity is an online retailer specializing in authentic autographed sports memorabilia. The company offers a wide range of collectibles, including signed jerseys, photos, and various sports memorabilia from major leagues such as MLB, NFL, and NBA. Each item is premium authenticated and comes with a Certificate of Authenticity (COA), ensuring that customers receive genuine products.
Targeting sports enthusiasts, collectors, and fans, Sports Integrity caters to individuals seeking to enhance their memorabilia collections or find unique gifts for fellow sports lovers. With a diverse inventory that includes items from notable athletes across different sports, the company aims to provide a reliable source for authentic collectibles that celebrate the achievements of sports icons.
Sports Integrity has a positive customer experience.
Sports Integrity receives high praise from customers, with many highlighting the great quality of products and the fast shipping service. Reviewers frequently mention their satisfaction with the timely delivery and careful packaging, ensuring items arrive in excellent condition.
Read full summaryShow less
Many express their intent to order again, citing smooth purchasing experiences and impressive merchandise. However, some customers report issues with receiving incorrect items or missing components, such as certificates of authenticity, despite paying extra for expedited shipping. Additionally, a few reviews note concerns about packaging quality, with some items arriving with minor damage. Overall, the majority of feedback reflects a positive sentiment towards Sports Integrity, emphasizing their reliable service and product quality.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.7
551
100%
-0.3
● Low
4.7 / 5 overall
=
551 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jun 2025.
Last 3 months
4.5▼ 0.3
12-month avg
4.7
All-time
4.7
Category avg
4.1
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Jul 24
5.0
6
Aug 24
5.0
13
Sep 24
5.0
1
Oct 24
4.4
10
Nov 24
5.0
12
Dec 24
4.6
30
Jan 25
4.6
11
Feb 25
5.0
4
Mar 25
4.8
6
Apr 25
4.0
6
May 25
4.7
3
Jun 25
4.8
6
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 453 positive reviews
Delivery47%
214 mentions
Fast & efficient43%
195 mentions
Customer service21%
93 mentions
Prices & value9%
42 mentions
“The process was very smooth and my purchase arrived within a few days”
On “Delivery” · Jun 21, 2025
Top complaintsof 32 negative reviews
Customer service22%
7 mentions
Refund19%
6 mentions
Quality19%
6 mentions
Shipping19%
6 mentions
“You lost a customer and may have gained a plaintiff”
On “Customer service” · Oct 6, 2024
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Collectibles.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
Paid over $100 extra for quicker shipping and just received today and it didn’t come with the advertised certificate of authenticity
They did refund my shipping costs. Still wondering about the certificate of authenticity.
William Johnson
Although they had run out of stock, they offered to reframe other photos by Friday. On Friday they posted that the item had missed the pickup time and would be sent out after the weekend. Sounds disappointing, but they were very good about keeping me posted on the status. I consider that great customer service. Thanks
What is Sports Integrity and what services do you provide?
Sports Integrity is a business focused on maintaining fairness and ethical standards in sports. We provide consulting services, integrity monitoring, and compliance solutions to help sports organizations maintain trust and transparency.
What are your business hours?
Please contact us directly for current business hours as they may vary by department and service type. Our customer service team can provide you with the most up-to-date schedule information.
How can I contact Sports Integrity?
You can reach us through our official website's contact form or by calling our main business line. We also maintain professional email addresses for different departments and inquiries.
What types of organizations do you work with?
We work with various sports organizations including professional leagues, amateur sports associations, and educational institutions. Our services are designed to support any organization committed to maintaining integrity in sports.
All 12 questions →Show fewer questions
Do you offer training programs for sports integrity?
We provide educational programs and training sessions focused on sports integrity principles. These programs are designed to help organizations and individuals understand and implement best practices for maintaining ethical standards.
What is your policy on confidentiality?
We maintain strict confidentiality standards in all our client relationships and investigations. All information shared with us is handled according to professional privacy guidelines and applicable legal requirements.
How do I report a potential integrity violation?
We have established reporting mechanisms for integrity concerns, which may include secure online portals or dedicated hotlines. Contact us directly to learn about the appropriate reporting channels for your specific situation.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Everything was fine except I thought it was framed can’t get message answered as to this question. I stand approved any shortcoming of the product is removed and I want to order a Simple Biles piece.
Really happy with the pictures, we're exactly the same as listed, but my nate diaz frame has a few scratches and scuffs. It doesn't ruin the picture but for the money you would think they would be flawless.
When I bought my jersey I used a payment option with an address I did'nt want to use and when I found out about it I immediately reached out to you people via email and was answered in a timely fashion, then when I found a phone number to call I did that and was answered in a timely fashion with the person on the other end being knowlegdable and friendly and we got everything taken care of and now I proudly display my jersey
The staff were extremely helpful and did a great job of helping me with my order, unfortunately it still hasn't arrived as of this post, but I can't blame this on the company as once it has left their hands it's up to the whims of USPS and we all know how they can be. Don't let that stop you from getting what you want from a wonderful company that will help you as much as possible.
Product was well packaged and arrived fairly quickly. Only issue and not sure if they framed it but there is a a tiny piece of framing paper over the signature that I will need to figure out how to open up the Frame and remove. Surprised they would sell/ship it like that.
I’m please with the item, which was exactly as advertised and took a week to arrive.
The way the item was shipped was disappointing. The ball came in a large cardboard box with one small sheet of bubble wrap—not enough to keep the ball from just flying all around in the box. The ball itself was poorly wrapped in a plastic sandwich bag stuffed in an open cardboard Rawlings box, same as if you bought a new baseball at a sports store.
Edit: The bubble wrap wasn’t secured around the ball at all. The box is probably 10x larger than the ball itself and largely unfilled, so nothing is keep the ball relatively stationary. Also, for $400 purchases a sandwich bag isn’t what I expected.
Ordered a Nolan Ryan baseball for my husband. Process was very easy and it arrived on time. The case for the baseball arrived broken but he uses another type anyway.
Do not need a case but thank you!
First of all, when I paid for shipping it was supposed to be UPS ground shipping, with an expected delivery date of January 3. The fact the package I ordered came via FedEx 3 days late on January 6 is the least of the problems with this order. The package arrived mangled, and the photo inside bent, creased, crumpled, and damaged. This is just flat out unacceptable. I would not buy from them again.
Edit: thank you for the reply. I wasn’t aware, I was just going by the tracking provided, which all said January 3 delivery date. Sorry about that. After speaking with the company president, he got the issue resolved so fast and offered me a full refund for the damaged product. Honestly, I’m astounded as customer service issues usually do not get resolved this quickly! This shows me that SportsIntegrity cares about the customer experience a lot. Although this order did not go as planned for me, I would be open to ordering from them again, and will give them the benefit of the doubt here with the damaged item.
Please contact us to discuss the geographic scope of our services. Our ability to work in different regions may depend on the specific type of service needed and local regulatory requirements.
What qualifications do your staff members have?
Our team consists of professionals with backgrounds in sports administration, law enforcement, legal compliance, and related fields. Many team members hold relevant certifications and have extensive experience in sports integrity matters.
How long does a typical integrity investigation take?
The timeline for investigations varies significantly depending on the complexity of the case and the scope of the inquiry. We work to complete all investigations as efficiently as possible while maintaining thoroughness and accuracy.
Do you provide ongoing monitoring services?
We offer various monitoring and compliance services designed to help organizations maintain integrity standards over time. These services can be customized based on the specific needs and requirements of each client.
What should I expect during the initial consultation?
During an initial consultation, we discuss your organization's specific needs and challenges related to sports integrity. We'll explain our relevant services and work with you to determine the best approach for your situation.
About Sports Integrity
Sports Integrity is an online retailer specializing in authentic autographed sports memorabilia. The company offers a wide range of collectibles, including signed jerseys, photos, and various sports memorabilia from major leagues such as MLB, NFL, and NBA. Each item is premium authenticated and comes with a Certificate of Authenticity (COA), ensuring that customers receive genuine products.
Targeting sports enthusiasts, collectors, and fans, Sports Integrity caters to individuals seeking to enhance their memorabilia collections or find unique gifts for fellow sports lovers. With a diverse inventory that includes items from notable athletes across different sports, the company aims to provide a reliable source for authentic collectibles that celebrate the achievements of sports icons.