Scoop Insurance is a Canadian insurance brokerage that specializes in providing comprehensive insurance solutions for auto, home, life, and commercial coverage. The company aims to simplify the insurance process for consumers by leveraging advanced technology to compare quotes from various providers, ensuring that clients receive tailored coverage options that fit their needs and budget.
Targeting both individual and business clients, Scoop Insurance is dedicated to helping over 100,000 Canadians protect their assets and manage their insurance policies efficiently. Through their online platform, myScoop, customers can easily access and manage their insurance documents, submit claims, and make payments, allowing for a streamlined and transparent experience in managing their insurance needs.
Scoop Insurance has a positive customer experience.
Scoop Insurance receives a mix of praise and criticism from its customers. Many reviewers highlight the excellent service and helpfulness of brokers like Hunter, Reina, and Markian, who provide clear explanations and support throughout the insurance process.
Read full summaryShow less
Consumers appreciate the reasonable rates and the overall positive experiences they have had when dealing with knowledgeable staff. However, there are significant complaints regarding the company's service, with several customers reporting issues such as unauthorized policy adjustments, lack of communication, and unprofessional behavior from brokers. Some feel misled by the information provided and express frustration over unresolved issues. Despite the positive experiences shared, the negative feedback about service consistency and communication cannot be overlooked.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
3.8
60
100%
-1.7
● Medium
3.8 / 5 overall
=
60 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Sep 2025.
Last 3 months
2.7▼ 1.7
12-month avg
3.8
All-time
3.8
Category avg
4.3
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Feb 25
2.3
3
Mar 25
2.0
8
Apr 25
4.7
31
May 25
3.5
8
Jun 25
3.7
3
Jul 25
3.7
3
Aug 25
1.0
1
Sep 25
2.3
3
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 60 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 42 positive reviews
Customer service31%
13 mentions
Fast & efficient29%
12 mentions
Helpful support26%
11 mentions
Prices & value24%
10 mentions
“Excellent service and policy quote was also very reasonable”
On “Customer service” · Jul 24, 2025
Top complaintsof 18 negative reviews
Customer service44%
8 mentions
Cancellation17%
3 mentions
Payment issues11%
2 mentions
No response11%
2 mentions
“I got an amazing quote from the Broker for car and home and wanted to proceed with it, however, the broker disappeared”
On “Customer service” · Sep 3, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Insurance.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
This company went ahead and adjusted my policy without my consent. I went from 1800 a year for car insurance to 4900. I only caught this looking through my emails. They added my son to my policy when i asked what it would look like if he was on it. Now im having to pay them for breaking my contract. This would be the 3rd month in a row of issues Ive had with them.
I got an amazing quote from the Broker for car and home and wanted to proceed with it, however, the broker disappeared. Not sure if anything happened, hope all is well with him, but he became unreachable by email and phone. At the same time spam calls to my phone number increased, so I wonder if this company is legit or is just phishing info for other purposes.
I wouldn’t recommend using scoop insurance. They tell you information that isn’t true and don’t help to resolve any issues. Even when notes are written from a previous employee that says you spoke they just repeat themselves as oh we can’t help you with this concern. I would look elsewhere if you need insurance because they won’t protect you.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
I wouldn't recommend scoop insurance to anybody. They lie about their policies, when you try to contact them to resolve an issue they completely ignore you, then add negative comments to your abstract. The agents are extremely rude, ignoring your request or concerns while trying to speak down at you. Anywhere else is better than this garbage.
If I could, I would give them a -5.
All those who praise this company in their reviews likely have never encountered a difficult situation with them. The company is comprised of irresponsible and unprofessional employees whose primary objective is to collect your money. In the event of any dispute or confusion, they will absolve themselves of responsibility and redirect you to the insurance provider. And guess what the insurance provider will tell you? That you are insured through a broker, and therefore all inquiries must be directed to the broker.
They also refuse to participate in a three-way conference call to resolve issues collaboratively.
Reaching anyone in a position of authority is practically impossible — everyone you can reach claims to be the highest authority available.
And don’t be misled by their responses here expressing regret and asking you to contact them to resolve the issue. Of course they write that — they’re not complete fools. But over the phone, when it's not a public forum, if you contact them with a problem, you’ll hear the same answer every time: “We can't help you. Please contact your insurance company.”
Therefore, think carefully before entering into any agreements through this broker.
I got a quote from Matt Hartstone at scoop insurance and I gave him my credit card and all the information that is required to get the insurance, This was on May 7, 2025 and now he will not answer my phone calls or emails. If there is a problem with my insurance quote it would be professional to answer my questions.
Every year when I try to go view the renewal documents, I get an error message and have to call to have them sent by email. No one ever replies to emails in time at this company. I encounter issues with them every single year. If the employees are not able to answer customers' emails, why aren't they redirected to another agent?
I am so frustrated. It is the same dance every time I try to get in contact with someone.
I also received my renewal for tenant insurance.... I had asked to remove my ex-partner off the policy LAST YEAR. Why is his name on the renewal?
Also, when I first moved to my current house and set up the home insurance, they had put my OLD address and I was paying for insurance somewhere I was not living at FOR AN ENTIRE YEAR.... they did not offer any type of compensation what so ever. They honestly just suck.
Their customer service is completely unacceptable.
The absolute worst customer service I have ever experienced. Like another reviewer here, I had a broker who seemed invested in finding some options since my current policies (that they brokered) went up 40% at renewal for absolutely no reason. Said she would email me a few options. She only emails me the one option we already decided wasn’t going to work for me while on the phone earlier, and when I left her a voicemail a couple days later to follow up, she told me she was too busy to talk to me so I would need to call again to find someone else to help me. Second person was even worse. This is the one and only time in my life I have lost my patience like that, but after three hours of being screwed around and no one could provide me with any answers I ended up hanging up in a rage.
An hour later I had insurance in place with Belair Direct for less than I paid the previous year with scoop/pembridge and cancelled my renewal with scoop.
Save your time and your sanity and go with another company.
No customer service, no response and no accountability. The staff will not do their job or respond. Staff make so many errors that you can't even get corrected. Completely incompetent employees and managers. Most of the staff do not want to deal with anything or keep their word. Very dishonest company. You can't get help when calling in, on the chat, emailing, asking for follow up to get help will get you no response. The managers do not care to do their job, so why would the employees care to do their job. No one follows up after repeated requests. People should report this to the insurance companies directly as this company should not have any contracts with any companies. They have a F rating on Better Business Bureau. They don't respond to fix the issues, they don't want to deal with anything or improve. It is not worth the stress and time dealing with Scoop. Try anyone else and you will see will see a difference in customer service. This company takes no ownership and seems to have a policy in place to not provide customer service and ignore customers. Look at all the reviews that are negative as they are honest and show clearly that Scoop ignores the issues and will not respond to fix the issues. Same issues reported over and over, poor customer service, dishonest staff, no response, errors and costs customers more because they are not an honorable company. I do not know how such a terrible company is still in business. Believe the negative reviews as they are showing to be weary and stay away from this company if you want customer service. I would give them zero stars, if I could. Our money should not go to a company that willingly shows that customer service is not important. Stay clear of this company, save your time, money and be free of the stress this company will cause. You will be grateful to not have to deal with Scoop. Listen to the warnings and F rating. I hope more people speak up about this horrible company.
Wouldn't recommend if it was the last place to get insurance.
I was assigned a case worker to help me with setting up a policy. His name is Tristan. Initially he seemed invested in helping me find a policy that fit my needs, but after a couple days I realized I couldn't be more wrong. He gave me misinformation about one policy, told me the best way to contact him was by email, and I've been waiting 2-4 business days for EACH REPLY. He simply stopped replying to me and after two weeks I still don't have a policy.
Just go to your local broker or insurance supplier. Scoop has great marketing and terrible service. Wouldn't recommend.
I want to talk about an insurance agent with scoop insurance her name is Cassandra McAlpine she did give a quote and mentioned that she will get back to me on the same day after sh gets a certain report she was waiting for, that happened on March 06 and now we are March 20th and didn't hear back from her yet, i tried email her 2 times and called her 2 times as well but no reply. I decided to call the main office but the wait was an hour anyways Cassandra's customer service was not professional don't recommend her at all.
I have just cancelled my insurance with Scoop and renewed with a new, local broker. I finally had had it with the errors and the terrible customer support. My call last week to cancel my home and auto policies took over half an hour to complete and when I received the e-docs to sign, they had someone else’s name on them! Hilarious.
Scoop Insurance is a Canadian insurance brokerage that specializes in providing comprehensive insurance solutions for auto, home, life, and commercial coverage. The company aims to simplify the insurance process for consumers by leveraging advanced technology to compare quotes from various providers, ensuring that clients receive tailored coverage options that fit their needs and budget.
Targeting both individual and business clients, Scoop Insurance is dedicated to helping over 100,000 Canadians protect their assets and manage their insurance policies efficiently. Through their online platform, myScoop, customers can easily access and manage their insurance documents, submit claims, and make payments, allowing for a streamlined and transparent experience in managing their insurance needs.