Skip to main content
JR Cigars logo

JR Cigars reviews & trust report

JR Cigars is an established online retailer specializing in a wide selection of premium cigars and cigar accessories. The company offers an extensive inventory that includes well-known brands, limited editions, and unique blends, catering to both casual smokers and seasoned aficionados. Customers can explore a variety of products, including cigars, humidors, and smoking accessories, all available for convenient online purchasing. The target market for JR Cigars includes cigar enthusiasts, gift buyers, and individuals seeking quality smoking experiences. By providing detailed product descriptions and customer reviews, the company aims to enhance the shopping experience and assist customers in making informed choices. With a focus on customer satisfaction, JR Cigars strives to meet the needs of its clientele by offering competitive pricing and reliable shipping options.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview86 customer reviews

JR Cigars has a poor customer experience.

JR Cigars receives overwhelmingly negative feedback from customers, with a significant number expressing frustration over poor customer service and order fulfillment issues. Many reviewers report receiving incorrect or incomplete orders, with some even receiving empty boxes.

Read full summary

Complaints about the quality of cigars are common, as customers mention receiving dried-out products or items that do not match their expectations. While a few consumers appreciate the fast delivery and have had satisfactory experiences, these positive remarks are overshadowed by the majority of negative reviews highlighting problems with shipping delays and unresponsive customer support. Additionally, concerns about pricing tactics and loyalty program changes further contribute to dissatisfaction.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
1.7/ 5
Mostly negative
Recent reviews: 15% happy · 83% unhappy

Best for

  • Customer service
  • Delivery
  • Fast & efficient

Watch out for

  • Customer service
  • Shipping
  • Pricing
86 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
1.7
100%
1.7 / 5 overall
86 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
1.3▲ 0.3
12-month avg
1.5
All-time
1.7
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewSep 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 2.3 from 3 reviewsNov 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsDec 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJan 25: 5.0 from 1 reviewFeb 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewMar 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewMay 25: 1.3 from 3 reviewsJun 25: 1.5 from 2 reviewsJul 25: 1.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.01
Sep 241.02
Oct 242.33
Nov 241.02
Dec 241.02
Jan 255.01
Feb 251.01
Mar 251.01
Apr 25—0
May 251.33
Jun 251.52
Jul 251.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 86 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 13 positive reviews

  • Customer service69%
    9 mentions
  • Delivery62%
    8 mentions
  • Fast & efficient31%
    4 mentions
  • Prices & value31%
    4 mentions
“I have completed two orders with JR Cigars with no issues”
On “Customer service” · Oct 23, 2024

Top complaintsof 71 negative reviews

  • Customer service61%
    43 mentions
  • Shipping31%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing15%
    11 mentions
  • Refund15%
    11 mentions
“just absolutely terrible customer service”
On “Customer service” · Jul 3, 2025

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Shopping & Fashion.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
JR Cigars logo
JR Cigars
1.7 out of 5 (poor)86
1.3 out of 5 (poor)1,000
2.9 out of 5 (fair)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)397
2.6 out of 5 (poor)368

Bottom line: JR Cigars is #4 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On service, Red Run scores higher (5.0 vs 1.5).

Reviews

86 reviews of JR Cigars. Filter by what matters to you.

1.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (86)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Kerim Barbur
Kerim Barbur
1 review

Terrible and unreliable

I order some cigars which were available and I get a good deal because of a coupon and fair prices , and the full amount is debited on my credit card they ship the package and after I receive it, I get an email saying that some items were not available and ı would be credited. I should have been warned before the package was shipped out, I go to double down on the part that was available and ı see that they bumped the prices by 40% on what's available. never seen such a thing before.

Report
Tom
Tom
1 review

Their customer service makes the DMV and airlines look good.

I ordered cigars on sept 14th with the “best shipping” method 3-8 days with USPS for $8.99. The tracking number shows them in transit in NC since the 15th. I have called their customer service, and was told they won’t even track it until it is 14 business days old. The rep seemed annoyed that I was inquiring to the whereabouts of the shipment. They still won’t track them on Oct. 3rd and do not seem to care at all. I am going to dispute the charge with the credit card company. Then they can track down the dry cigars and take them back to the warehouse.

Report
Jon
Jon
1 review

Order placed 20 days ago

Order placed 20 days ago. Never received it. Tracking shows it was lost in transit. JR customer service refusing to give me a refund and refusing to reship it. I’ve contacted them 6 times. Do not give these people your money

Report
Bob Kuyper
Bob Kuyper
1 review

Getting shipments of cigars I did not order.

Got a few boxes of Tabak Especial cigars and was satisfied. This past month I am being shipped cigars I did not order and billed on my credit card. Do not trust them with putting a credit card on file!

Report
Jonathan Jones

Can't seem to stop there unwanted spams

Everyday for the past several years I get about five or six email spams from JR cigars. In these past couple years I've talked on the phone with their customer service a good 20 times plus, every time being assured that the email would stop and that they would take care of it. Nothing ever seems to happen I guess they have a habit of just sweeping it under the rug. Well looking through all the reviews apparently many other people have the same complaint. I wish I didn't even have to give you one star a tenth of a star would be more like it. I read reviews of Jr'cigars on BBB and they graded the company with a letter grade of f. I'll be going there next to write another review with them.

Report
pc
pc
1 review

Worst service in the world

Worst service in the world. DO not purchase anything from this company! They take your order and say they ship next day, never ships and they never call or email you. When you call about the shipment status they say some issue with the address approval, we have purchased from this company in the past, when you ask what the issue is they can't tell you and they will call you back in 24-48 hours, are kidding if I could wait I would not had paid for next day delivery. Again, this company is a big JOKE, don't do business with this company!!!

Report
John Jabkowski

JR Cigars

According to JR Cigars, their system go hacked and thus my internal JR cigar account got hacked. Now the only way for me to place orders with them is to get a new e-mail address, what a sham this is, I have been working in IT for 30 + years and to say to an person to go get another e-mail address because our system go hacked is a disgrace.

Report
Buck
Buck
1 review

Horrbile

Horrbile. 8 days after ordering cigars I have no idea if or when they'll ship. Called them and was told it looks like the order was pulled but had no info? First and last time!! Should've just stuck with CI where I get my cigars within a few days. Lesson learned. BEWARE!!

Report
Anthony Griffis

My experience has been horrendous

My experience has been horrendous. I ordered some cigars for my boyfriend's birthday, and they were never even shipped, was never even contacted. I cancelled the order and wanted a full refund of $148. I received $91.58, and I didn't receive ANYTHING from them. It has been over 2 weeks since I cancelled and I just now got refunded, and it wasn't even the full amount. I will NEVER EVER order from this company again.

Report
elizabeth s
elizabeth s
1 review

JR CIGARS SENDS OUT BOCUS DISCOUNT CODES

JR CIGARS SENDS OUT BOCUS DISCOUNT CODES

Report
Jean Reyes
Jean Reyes
1 review

False advertisement,waste of time…

False advertisement,waste of time curating my order, didn't acknowledge the 25% off....

Report
Billnj
Billnj
1 review

I have been a JR customer for over 30…

I have been a JR customer for over 30 years and have spent thousands with them. About 18 months ago my acct got hacked and my credit card was compromised. The only erroneous charge was at JR. So I canceled my credit card and informed JR. They in turn canceled my account and will not reinstate without a NEW email address What a moronic thing to do. Apparently I am to go through the hassle setting up a new email in my various computer just for the privilege of being their customer. I wish Lou still owned the company. So good by to JR and hello to CI. Hopefully they don’t have the Sam tecnoweney running their customer avoidance system

Report
Eric Brown
Eric Brown
1 review

Never Again

I rarely post negative reviews but I am out of patience. On 4/1 I ordered a box of cigars. On 4/6 they were out for delivery per UPS. Then around two that afternoon, which is about the time our normal driver gets here, the status changed stating a problem with the address. I called JR. The agent was very kind and called UPS and told me there was an issue with the format of the address that she corrected and they would still show up that day. Well they did not show up. So the next day the UPS tracking information said check back tomorrow for updated delivery information. That was 4/7 and this is 4/14, that status has not changed. I have been on the phone with JR each day and up until today everyone was nice even if ineffective. Today the rep was not only ineffective but rude. She could not have cared less that her employer was holding 190 dollars of my money hostage for two weeks while I had no product. Look, I get there is an issue with UPS on this one. But it has been two weeks and I do not have an agreement with UPS, I have an agreement with JR Cigars. I should not still be waiting for my money back. An absolute imbecile can see the package has been lost or more likely stolen. I even went out to the UPS depot where this package would be. The manager looked for 37 minutes and found nothing. All we know for sure is that it was out for delivery and then suddenly it wasn't. That seems simple enough to me. This is a problem between JR and UPS that has now become my problem. I have the bank involved now too. Obviously I will never purchase anything else from JR Cigars or Cigars.com or any other business that shares their address. This has been a very bad experience because I have had shipping issues with other companies and they took so much better care of me than JR has. And moving forward those companies will see all of my business. Take this as a warning to not do business with these people. They are fine with the taking your money part but as soon as there is a problem all you will get is the runaround. I never asked for anything special. All I wanted was someone to exercise some common sense and return my money. One way or the other I will get my money back. And I will be posting this review everywhere I can find until I do!

Report
Paul
Paul
1 review

Paid for overnight shipping and…

Paid for overnight shipping and received 5 days later...worthless customer service.

Report
H. E.
H. E.
1 review

Life long cigar smoker

Life long cigar smoker, 50+ years. JR has terrible customer service. They packed 3 orders with cigars lose in large box with items like humidor, promo knife and such beating cigars up. They wiped quite a few auction wins from my account within an hour of winning, I feel ripped off by jr cigar. I'll never buy from them again. Cigarbid is awesome.

Report
Stephen Parsons

Stay Away!!

Stay Away!!! Order placed on the weekend. Order not filled until Wed following week and told shipping would take 3-8 bus days. Called Cust Svs and their response is we're sorry, "we don't know what's going on with fullfilment" - "we just take the orders", no assistance provided or resolution offered. I will NEVER order from this place again. Go to Best Price Cigars, they are much more responsive and ship within 24 hours.

Report
Jan Hochfeld
Jan Hochfeld
1 review

Stay away! They will spam you with emails and you can’t stop them

The cigars and prices are OK. You can find better usually. DO NOT SIGN UP FOR THE EMAIL LIST!!! I have been unsubscribing to try to get off it for the last 10 days and today I received 6 e-mails. I have been a long time customer, and accidentally subscribed during checkout. Now I am blocking all emails from their domain and they will have to loose my business because that I won’t be receiving any of their mails. It’s ok. Customer service and quality have gone downhill over the last few years…

Report
Mickey Sharma

The worst online cigar retailer

The worst online cigar retailer. They lie about delivery times and options. Their customer service is extremely unreliable and lie to the customer. I called JR cigar on Friday Sept 10 to order this for a trip to Florida leaving Sept 16. I asked tustomer service what method of shipping would get this to me in time for my trip as it was my responsibility to provide the cigars for the company executives. I ordered this travel humidor, a second humidor, boveda packs, and cigars . They said UPS 2nd day air. would DEFINITELY get it to me on time if I ordered by Sept 14. I placed the order Sept 13 and checked off UPS 2nd day air as per their suggestion. Extremely disappointed that my order arrived on Sept 20, after I had already returned from Florida. What an embarrassing trip as the only 1 thing that 1 needed to do right was derailed by JR Cigar. I called them Sept 20 and they acted like they couldn't care less and offered "25% off YOUR NEXT ORDER". Who in their right mind would order from JR Cigar "next time" if they can't even get the order right the first time. I asked them if they would make any concession for THIS ORDER WHICH THEY SCREWED UP but they gave me the cold shoulder and said "send it back if you are unsatisfied". Wow! What absolutely horrific customer service. Doesn't get any worse than this. They don't give a rats a$$ about their customers. JR Cigar thinks that if you send the order back and they return your money, then that rights their wrong. They have no intention of establishing a relationship between them and their customers. JR Cigar is just a greedy, online cigar retailer. There are lots of better cigar retailers that actually offer decent customer service and not the sorry excuse of customer service that JR cigar offers.

Report
Derron Smith
Derron Smith
1 review

Let me start my review by saying

Let me start my review by saying, I have been a JR Cigar customer for over a decade. With that said, I was duped into purchasing their flat rate $39.99 annual shipping program. Let me just say, those were the slowest method they could have possibly conceived. After the first year, they asked if I wanted to renew and I let them know under no uncertain terms, NO! Since then, I've been trying to be patient as possible with the orders. The entire year 2020 the excuse was, we're suffering from the pandemic. What's the excuse 2021? Which brings me to today's complaint. I placed an order over 2 weeks ago with expedited shipping, contacted 3 customer service representative oh, one more nonchalant in the next. When calling today, the lady tells me that the box was at my door. I was literally standing at my door. Now I have to do the legwork and track them through USPS. I just wanted to cancel my order, would not let me do it. Again, over 10 years as a customer and thousands of dollars spent. My only advice to you buyer beware! I will be finding another provider for my cigar needs.

Report
Coolbreeze
Coolbreeze
1 review

Bait and switch

I received a email from JR Cigars with a 20% discount coupon on May 20. 2021. The next day I wanted to use the coupon it was declined, so I called customer service and inquired why the coupon was declined. After being on the phone for almost 20 minutes this was their answer: We don't accept coupons on items we discounted already. When I said there was nothing written or stated on the coupon regarding use or exceptions, I was told that's the way it is." Practically every item would be on sale at JR Cigars the state the retail price and then how much you save with their price. Example: Retail Price$238.80 JR Price$195.87 You Save$42.93 The coupon seems like a bait and switch nothing more. This was written on the coupon without a disclaimer or restrictions regarding its use. It's been a while since we last saw you and we think it's about time you treat yourself to another perfect smoke. Come explore our vast selection of hand-rolled cigars at unbeatable prices and treat yourself to a special 20% off. Use code: NWB-2DF2-DFGV-IT2S-I4OV

Report

Alternatives to JR Cigars

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.