Skip to main content
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals reviews & trust report

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals specializes in providing a diverse selection of vacation rental properties along the Gulf Shores and Orange Beach areas. The company offers a range of accommodations, including condos and beach houses, catering to families, couples, and groups seeking a memorable getaway. With an extensive portfolio of properties, Brett/Robinson aims to meet the varying needs of vacationers looking for beachfront access, modern amenities, and a comfortable stay. The company’s website, www.brett-robinson.com, features an easy-to-navigate platform where customers can browse available rentals, check rates, and make reservations. Targeting individuals and families interested in vacationing in Alabama's coastal regions, Brett/Robinson provides essential information to help guests plan their ideal vacation experience.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview1,000 customer reviews

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals receives a mix of feedback from customers, with a notable portion expressing dissatisfaction. Many reviewers appreciate the quality of the condos, highlighting comfortable beds and well-maintained units, particularly at locations like Phoenix IX.

Read full summary

However, numerous complaints arise regarding cleanliness and maintenance issues, with reports of mold infestations, bed bugs, and dirty linens in various units. Customers also voice frustration over poor customer service, including long wait times for check-in and unresponsive staff. While some guests commend individual team members for their assistance, the overall sentiment reflects significant concerns about the condition of the properties and the company's handling of issues. Consequently, the prevailing sentiment leans towards the negative.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.0/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 62% happy · 21% unhappy

Best for

  • Friendly staff
  • Helpful support
  • Easy to use

Watch out for

  • Payment issues
  • Pricing
  • Defective product
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.0
100%
4.0 / 5 overall
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jul 2025.

Last 3 months
2.0
12-month avg
1.3
All-time
4.0
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Aug 24SepOctNovDecJan 25FebMarAprMayJunJul 25Category avg 4.0Aug 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsOct 24: 1.0 from 2 reviewsJun 25: 1.0 from 1 reviewJul 25: 3.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Aug 241.02
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.02
Nov 24—0
Dec 24—0
Jan 25—0
Feb 25—0
Mar 25—0
Apr 25—0
May 25—0
Jun 251.01
Jul 253.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 308 positive reviews

  • Friendly staff17%
    52 mentions
  • Helpful support16%
    50 mentions
  • Easy to use10%
    30 mentions
  • Customer service7%
    22 mentions
“The staff here are very friendly and helpful and the premises are immaculate”
On “Friendly staff” · Sep 14, 2020

Top complaintsof 106 negative reviews

  • Payment issues21%
    22 mentions
  • Pricing11%
    12 mentions
  • Defective product10%
    11 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    10 mentions
“I am staying at Phoenix I, and someone threw a white powdery water mix on one side of my black car”
On “Payment issues” · Oct 28, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals logo
Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals
4.0 out of 5 (good)1,000
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals is #5 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On value, Alfa Travel scores higher (4.6 vs 2.9).

Reviews

500 reviews of Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.0ⓘ

Customer reviews (1,000)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Jennifer
Jennifer
1 review

Completely Disappointed

I have been traveling from Texas to the Orange Beach/Gulf Shores area for vacation and staying in a Brett Robinson vacation rental for the last 20 years. I was reluctant to go to the beach this year due to the pandemic, but really needed the trip for mental health and felt this option was possibly the safest one. The check in/out times are ridiculous. 5:00 is very late when you are trying to get organized for your stay and our room was not even ready at that time. 10:00 departure really cuts off needed time to take in the last few hours of vacation and leave without feeling frantic. We stayed at Phoenix East and upon check in, the front desk staff were less than friendly. Beyond signs that outlined social distancing and safety protocol, nothing was mentioned or emphasized. In fact, it seemed they could care less. The room was out dated in multiple ways, including ripped balcony chairs, a missing lounger chair that was shown in the room advertisement pictures, old appliances, the bathtub drain was clogged up, the coffee maker was dirty and burnt, and the refrigerator temperature could not be regulated appropriately freezing our food. As far as the behavior I saw from most people, it was like a pandemic was not even a thing. There was no hand sanitizer leading to the pool area, I never saw commonly used handrails being disinfected and the beach was absolutely packed. I know the chair/umbrella rental company is a separate business, but surely people talk to each other. They were set up not only NOT socially distanced, but crammed together. It was impossible to not be enveloped in a sea of people who gave no mind to safety. Part of me did not want to write a negative review, but with as much money that is invested in a stay with Brett Robinson, I have come to expect way more.

Report
Brian
Brian
1 review

Old , dirty and outdated units

We rented 2 condos in Phoenix VI, units 6608 and 6409. We have been renting from Brett Robinson for over 30 years and I’ve never been more disappointed in two units before. Both were dirty with hair in all corners of the rooms, grungy carpet in 6608 and blood stain on pillow in 6409. There was no tv in one of the bedrooms in 6608 and it wasn’t advertised as such. 6409 had 3 cups and almost no cookware. BR was receptive and bought new cooking ware on day 3 but someone should be checking that. The bathroom shower door was disgusting with black spots and peeling silicone everywhere. I would expect that at a cheap motel , not a $400 a night condo. Phoenix condos used to be nice but I think Brett Robinson needs to urge their owners to update units and get better cleaning crews, especially with the supposedly new COVID cleaning they are doing. I would be hesitant to to stay with BR again.

Report
John
John
1 review

Phoenix X

Stayed at Phoenix X last week with family in unit 1412. The condo was very dirty especially the floors . The silverware had food caked on most pieces as did many of the plates and pots present in the condo. The view was nice and we enjoyed the balcony. It was disappointing to see how dirty the condo was especially in the midst of the COVID pandemic . First thing we did when we arrived was go to Publix and buy cleaning supplies ( as well as incidentals like toilet paper and dish soap as they don’t provide anything but a single roll of toilet paper ) and clean the whole place .

Report
Shala Sartin Waid

WE STAYED IN PHOENIX 1 CONDO NUMBER…

WE STAYED IN PHOENIX 1 CONDO NUMBER 1092. WHEN WE GOT THERE THE SHEETS WERE STAINED UP BAD. THERE WAS A DIRTY RAZOR IN THE SHOWER. SAND WAS ALL OVER THE FLOOR. I KNOW AT THE BEACH THERE IS SAND BUT YOU COULD TELL THE FLOOR HAD NOT BEEN CLEANED. THERE WERE DIRTY DISHES IN THE ROOM. THE LIGHTING WAS HORRIBLE. THE CODE FOR OUR DOOR HAD TO BE REDONE 3 DIFERENT TIMES BECAUSE THE CODE WOULD NOT OPEN THE DOOR. THE CEILING AND WALLS NEED TO BE CLEANED THERE WERE SPOTS ALL OVER THEM AND THE FURNITURE AND THE RUG IN THE LIVING ROOM PART WERE STAINED UP. THE WASHER AND DRYER TOOK FOREVER TO WASH AND DRY! THE WASHER LID WAS BENT SO IT DIDNT EVEN CLOSE GOOD. THE TOWELS THAT WERE IN THE ROOM GOT FUZZ ALL OVER EVERYTHING EVEN AFTER THEY WERE WASHED! THE TV IN THE MASTER ROOM WOULD NOT WORK. THERE WERE NO EXTRA BLANKETS AT ALL FOR US TO USE ON THE PULL OUT COUCH! JUST OVER ALL BAD ROOM EXPERIENCE. WE HAVE ALWAYS LOVED ANY OF THE PHOENIX ROOMS BUT THIS ONE NEEDS SOME WORK DONE AND NEEDS TO BE CLEANED ESPECIALLY FOR THE AMOUNT OF MONEY WE SPENT TO STAY A WEEK!

Report
Nicole
Nicole
1 review

We stayed at Island Wind East

We stayed at Island Wind East. The location is great (opposite side of the hustle and bustle). However , i was not satisfied with the furniture. The sofa cushions and pillows smelled old and musty. It appeared that they had never been washed. I can say the same for the bedding. The pillows on the beds had an ‘old’ smell. I was very thankful that I had packed my own pillow from home. Also, when i booked the condo, it showed $92/night but once I booked it, my total bill was $700 I didn’t appreciate the false advertisement

Report
Mr. Sparks
Mr. Sparks
1 review

Nice Condos, Low Budget Features

I’ll start with the positives: location is great, amenities are good, huge balcony in unit, open layout is great. This was our second stay at one of the Phoenix West condos (we stayed at II last year) and were very pleased - plus the kids love the water slide and lazy river at both of the PWs. Unfortunately- our unit was very disappointing. The most disappointing aspect was the mattresses in the unit. They were awful. Absolutely no way of getting a good nights sleep on any of the four beds. You could literally feel the springs in the master bed and underneath was a rollaway metal frame. The bed setup was very low budget. My family left longing for our own beds and a good nights sleep- not rejuvenate the way you would hope after a few days of vacation. Decent bed accommodations is something Marriotts and Westin’s do much better. Additionally, the dishwasher was a terrible, low budget, example of a dishwasher that did a poor job washing dishes. I have family members who own condos on the beach and I know how frustrating it can be dealing with renters who tear up things and do not respect the property they are staying at. I get that. But it’s no excuse to not use better beds and mattresses in one of the nicest condos in Orange Beach. We won’t be back to PW I (Unit 1201).

Report
Larry
Larry
1 review

P2 worst stay ever after 20 yrs of doing business with you

P2 , room 9004. Hard to give a good review with a room that has wind blowing around door and cold air coming in the whole time we were there. Reported this and either they did nothing or what they did , did not correct the problem. Tried to call and tried to report again but no one their except few hours each day. Was told at check out someone call and have not heard anything from you. Seems like we may have to find somewhere that cares for their clients room price is ok but all other fees and 350$ to price. Way to much

Report
H Weeden
H Weeden
1 review

Phoenix I-1116 Old & Worn

Phoenix I-1116. Fantastic view and a comfortable bed. Those are the only positive things I can say about this unit. The carpet needs replacing and is dirty, as is the furniture. Trim is broken off the furniture. The refrigerator looks bad, and the stove is 29 years old. Very limited cook ware. Wind whistled through the unit so loud (with the doors closed) it woke us up. Washcloths were not provided with linen package. Came up from the pool and found maintenance in our bathroom with no prior notice. He removed the bathroom exhaust fan and it still wasn't replaced when we left. TVs are WAY too small for the rooms. Could take out the VCR and CD player and make room for modern technology. Exorbitant B/R fees do not include beach chairs, which were not available anyway. No chance I would ever return to a Brett/Robinson property!

Report
M T
M T
1 review

Parking was terrible here

Parking was terrible here, not enough elevators for a huge complex, after 4 getting into our condo for such high rental price , Terrible internet service and had no service on our phones a lot!!! Would love a partial refund to have paid over 600 night !!!! Not going back here!!!

Report
Melanie Carter

Phoenix III Room 3047

We stayed at Phoenix III in room 3047 May 30 - June 2, 2019. The shower/tub stopper was held up with a sting tied to the shower head and the mattress was awful. You could feel the springs in your back, must have been very old! Normally we are very pleased at any of the Phoenixes but this one was falling apart and out of date!

Report
Latrella
Latrella
1 review

The kiddie pool was down then they shut…

The kiddie pool was down then they shut the water off to the condo while I was taking a shower they never let us aware that the water was going to be shut off it was down for over a hour

Report
Wayne Leischner

Things that need to be fixed or replaced.

I strongly believe that as the company representing the owners of the condos, you should have a responsibility to inspect said condos to be sure they are safe and deemed furnished adequately for occupancy. The furnace in ours (#676) is blowing large amounts of dirt through the system in such large quantities that the ceiling, near the vents, is virtually coated with dirt and dust. A furnace repairman looked at it and said it cannot be repaired or corrected. It must be replaced. Secondly, the cooking utensils are of the cheapest ones available. The only way an egg could be cooked would be to poach it in butter. Thirdly, the sofa is unusable. It is so broken down, it is very difficult to get up and off of it because you would sink down so far in it. Please do not rent this unit out until you have corrected the above inadequate items.

Report
Keith
Keith
1 review

We have rented through Brett Robinson…

We have rented through Brett Robinson and the Phoenix Units for over 30 years, our unit, this year, was by far the most run down we have ever stayed in. Bedroom carpet was extremely dirty and the sofa was worn out and dirty. No working fan in second bath, not enough eating utensils for more than 4. The maintenance employees did correct the fan problem and made several attempts to repair the ice maker.

Report
Mervin
Mervin
1 review

The kitchen was poorly stocked

The kitchen was poorly stocked. We had cockroaches in our unit. The pool was not warm enough.

Report
Ed
Ed
1 review

Okay but no revisit!

Of two elevators for the building, one has been out of commission since before our arrival on 2/1 and remains so on departure. The door to the condo has given trouble, off and on, throughout; it took three calls to get it working better.. The building has NO lavatory on the ground level; the only lavatories are those in each condo unit. The condo itself badly needs one or two easy chairs, a couple of floor lamps, a ceiling light over the dining area and the island area; the bedrooms need hooks and place to place clothes overnight; one bathroom's shower curtain cannot remain in the tub on its own (the second or outer curtain must be used to keep the first ne in the tub); the "office staff" were barely civil and not in the least welcoming; parking was scarce as multiple spaces were allotted to construction/painting companies; the one balcony is quite narrow and small; heating/cooling had NO instructions whatsoever; TV equipment had poor instructions as to use. The condo was very well appointed/equipped with kitchen/cooking tools and implements. All in all, this is not a place we would revisit or recommend unequivocally.

Report
William and Pam

Why are we getting a notice "HOPE" you…

Why are we getting a notice "hope" you enjoyed your visit....really we are due to check in March 1, 2019. Who is running this site and not checking dates for your loyal customers who have been coming there for many years. They must be idot's. Two week before we are to arrive you left a message for our reservation made a year ago that we were unable to stay at the Phoenix 7 1517 due to the decks will be closed off. Really short notice but you took it upon yourself to put us in an inside unit at the same rate. Now really does that make any sense to you and I'm sure you wouldn't be very happy either??? I spent or wasted a day on the phone trying to get moved to a different and comperable unit. Finally found someone that did help us but now we are nervous that when we get there something will be messed up by incompetent people that don't know what they are doing! I'm sure this won't be posted on your site as you stated in your lovely email. You should be embarrassed to send out stuff like you did to us asking for how our visit was. Well hoping we do have our month rental reservation which I have called and confirmed but with people like this makes us nervous. You really need to clean house with the people that are sending this email out!!

Report
Ruth
Ruth
1 review

Bed broke 1st night

Bed broke 1st night . It was r,epaired next am.promised new bed as repair made with old parts found in basement by service man. Still waiting on new bed.just another promise from Brett Robinson crew. Patio covered with chips from building rework. This was not to happen which we were notified after we had rented with down payment.notice to desk no action so mess was cleaned by us. Weak water pressure for showers mentioned by other guests also. Rented from you in the 90s & early 2000s. No problems

Report
Karen
Karen
1 review

Unusable to use balcony from Jan4

Unusable to use balcony from Jan4; with no compensation for rent. Tv mounted on wall, in living room, no stand or shelf, components on the floor. Light over sink in kitchen out, maintaincy has tried to fix it twice.

Report
Jerry
Jerry
1 review

I had to cancel our reservation 2…

I had to cancel our reservation 2 months prior to our visit, and we were still charged a cancellation fee. I thought with that much notification the fee should be waived.

Report

Alternatives to Brett/Robinson Vacation Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.