Pet Supplies Plus is a retail chain that specializes in pet supplies and accessories for various types of pets. The stores typically offer products such as pet food, toys, grooming supplies, bedding, and other essentials for dogs, cats, birds, fish, and small animals. Many locations also provide services like pet grooming and may carry live animals such as fish and small pets.
Pet Supplies Plus receives a mixed reception from customers, with a significant number expressing dissatisfaction. While some reviewers appreciate the variety of supplies and the helpfulness of staff like Jacqui, many others report serious issues.
Read full summaryShow less
Complaints frequently highlight poor customer service, with instances of rude employees and unresponsive management. Customers also express frustration over online orders, citing problems with delivery and incorrect items received. Additionally, there are concerns about the health of animals sold in-store, with reports of sick fish and ferrets. Despite a few positive experiences, the overall sentiment leans heavily negative, reflecting a troubling trend in customer satisfaction.
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Why sources differ: Trustpilot rates this company 2.4, CrowdTrust 1.0. Trustpilot carries the most weight (97% of the score).
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
2.4
60
2.4 / 5 overall
=
62 reviews across 2 scored sources
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Nov 2025.
Last 3 months
1.0▼ 1.0
12-month avg
2.0
All-time
2.4
Category avg
4.3
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Dec 24
1.0
2
Jan 25
3.3
3
Feb 25
1.3
3
Mar 25
5.0
1
Apr 25
—
0
May 25
2.4
5
Jun 25
1.0
4
Jul 25
3.7
3
Aug 25
1.0
1
Sep 25
—
0
Oct 25
1.0
2
Nov 25
1.0
3
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 62 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 21 positive reviews
Customer service38%
8 mentions
Friendly staff24%
5 mentions
Helpful support24%
5 mentions
Easy to use19%
4 mentions
“This was my first time visiting the store and I got extremely lucky and was helped by
Jacqui at 32nd and Shea Blvd”
On “Customer service” · Jul 27, 2025
Top complaintsof 41 negative reviews
Customer service22%
9 mentions
Never received12%
5 mentions
Pricing12%
5 mentions
Charges10%
4 mentions
“I was a customer at the Doylestown, PA store for a few years until several months ago when I was literally yelled at...”
On “Customer service” · Nov 11, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Animals & Pets.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
This company has the most outdated technology I have seen. They send a discount to my account and to my email but the clerks have no record of it. I have to print my email and bring it to them. Most of the time it doesn't work. I have a $5 reward on my account that I have no access to because I can't log in to my account. I am done with this place.
Jeremy Shallop is among the WORST business owners in Taylor Michigan! His clerk Rianna at Pet Supplies Plus double charged our credit card and we never received our funds back! So we contacted her manager Sam who said it was nothing she do because it was Rianna's fault and then Sam passed the buck onto Jeremy Shallop the owner. In case we called Jeremy Shallop for weeks, he ignored our calls until finally calling our family back three weeks later. When Jeremy Shallop finally called us back he said quote " I do NOT care" unquote. Simply put whoever reads this please do everything in your power to stay away from 22124 Ecorse Road Taylor, Michigan 48180 as the employees there are truly incompetent people, poorly trained and as stated above the owner Jeremy Shallop cares absolutely nothing about paying customers who have been inconvenienced by his deplorable idiotic staff members. If our family could do so we would give his staff and him a negative 0 star rating.
This store in Ridgecrest Plaza is absolutely unbelievable. The place looks like a dump for one thing. I was in there a couple weeks ago and bought 31 lb bag of dog food and no one even offered to help me get it to my car, I'm a senior citizen and every place else cycle they asked if I want help. The icing on the cake was yesterday I ordered some things for delivery and my credit card was charged. Today I'm expecting the delivery and I get a call the two of the three things I ordered our unavailable. I asked the girl why they were available yesterday and I was able to put them in my card and my credit card was charged but the poor thing didn't know she just started so I just told her to tell the manager I am all done shopping at that store.
Most Pet Supplies Plus locations are open Monday through Saturday from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM, and Sunday from 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM. Store hours may vary by location and during holidays, so it's best to check with your local store for specific hours.
Does Pet Supplies Plus offer grooming services?
Yes, many Pet Supplies Plus locations offer full-service grooming including baths, haircuts, nail trims, and ear cleaning. Services and availability may vary by location, so contact your local store to schedule an appointment.
What is Pet Supplies Plus's return policy?
Pet Supplies Plus accepts returns within 60 days of purchase with a receipt for a full refund. Items must be in original condition and packaging, and live animals have specific return policies that vary by location.
Does Pet Supplies Plus sell live animals?
Yes, Pet Supplies Plus typically carries live animals including fish, birds, small animals like hamsters and guinea pigs, and reptiles. Availability varies by location, and some stores may have adoption events for cats and dogs.
All 10 questions →Show fewer questions
Do you offer a loyalty or rewards program?
Yes, Pet Supplies Plus offers a free loyalty program called the Preferred Pet Club. Members receive exclusive discounts, special offers, and earn points on purchases that can be redeemed for rewards.
Can I order online and pick up in store?
Yes, Pet Supplies Plus offers online ordering with curbside pickup and buy online, pick up in store options. You can place orders through their website or mobile app and select your preferred pickup method.
What brands of pet food does Pet Supplies Plus carry?
Pet Supplies Plus carries a wide variety of pet food brands including premium, natural, and specialty diet options for dogs, cats, birds, fish, and small animals. Popular brands include Blue Buffalo, Hill's, Purina, and their own private label products.
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Have ordered online twice for a pickup. First time waited outside 20 mins. Second time I kept waiting in the car and finally walked inside where an employee pointed to my 28 lb bag of dogfood on the floor behind the counter and told me there it is, let me get your receipt. Geez, I'm a 65 y/o female.. You think they would help. This store is in Portland Texas.
Went to the Raynham store in MA. I bought 2 items 1 $36.98 the other marked WAS$39.99 75% off NOW $10. I had a coupon code $10 off $40 plus a $5 reward. The subtotal should have been $36.98 + $10+ $46.98. The subtract the $15 for coupon/reward to equal $31.98. Nope, it came to $37.82. I went back and spoke with the manager who told me the coupon and reward come off the $39.99 THEN they take 75% off that. THIS IS ILLEGAL IN MASSACHUSETTS. The manager claims it is how there system works and no way to override it. I reported them to the Attorney General and won't ever shop there again. I have the receipt and bag with sticker for proof. I know they did the same thing last time I was in but couldn't figure out why the receipt was off. It was much easier with only 2 items.
Pet Supplies Plus is a farse. I worked just over 3 months at the new Orangeburg,SC so called facility. Around the time that you're getting your first pay raise, they're searching for a reason to fire you. My supervisor changed our work hours in my department. The very next morning at 6am, I had an argument with my so called supervisor. At first break the head boss came to get me, we were more than 3 hours behind from scheduled shipment. When my so called top of the line boss said he couldn't keep me any longer. I wouldn't advise my worst enemy to work for them.
Signed,
Clarence C. Stabler Jr
I was at the store in Naperville ill, and the store manager refused to sell me a .34-cent goldfish because I didn't have a fish tank with a heater, my brother went to the store and they sold him goldfish with no questions asked when I asked for the named of the manager she refuses to give me her name and she threatens to call the police. That manager is unprofessional. I called the corporate office and they said the district manager named Noe Sanchez would call me so far no one has called.
Store in Killeen TX is not worth the visit. Selection of products is great but the staff are arrogant and condescending. Simply can’t believe a dog owner might know more than they do about a specific breed. No way would I risk having a groom done there. Not worth the trouble to deal with them. Will stay with Amazon and PETCO.
I ordered an automatic litter box with the accompanying bags, after 2 weeks I had not received an order, after which I sent another email, everything would be sent and suddenly the website was offline, scammers!!!
Worst experience ever with a retailer of any kind! I had a standing auto-ship order for 3 items well over $100. day before auto-ship I check the website and it says that they are putting the order together. The day the shipment is supposed to arrive I notice a refund for my order, that was a real surprise because I'm expecting dog food, cat food and some kitty litter. So I call the store and speak to Justin that would not give me his last name. When I ask why my order is cancelled he explains that the dog food was not in stock. I ask the logical questions of [a] why do you have auto-ship and then not have the item in stock, what's the point [b] why didn't anyone notify my, I would have accepted a substitution. He started getting snippy with me and asked me to lower my voice when it was very much at a reasonable tone. So I Iowered my voice to just above a whisper and asked again. Then I told him that Chewy would never do this, but I was trying tpo keep my money local. He promptly told me to take my business to Chewy. I got pissed and told him where to go. Minutes later I called back to determine his last name so I could advise the owners of the company. At this point he threatened to have me put in jail if I ever called or step foot in "his" store. Wow, what a world class jerk! I'm left with no dog food, no cat food, no kitty litter and memories of a close encounter with the biggest store manager jerk in my 60 years of existence! Take your business elsewhere, this angry guy managing the store is reason alone to shop elsewhere. After shopping there for 22 years, I'm done!
Even before my rescue partnered with them, I didn't have much success with anything at this store. Employees were rude if they engaged with you at all. After my rescue partnered with them for cat adoptions, it was truly awful. Their so called manager Destiny has no clue how to be a manager. She's a pro at starting drama though. Their sometimes manager from out of town, Deb, will lie straight to your face then deny it later no matter who witnessed it. Their main manager, Matt is a rude arrogant jerk who doesn't know what respect means. Steer clear of this store. It's more drama than it's worth.
Bryan the rude manager wouldn't apply my $10 coupon from Pet Supplies Plus. He said I didn't spend enough money. I asked him where it said that the coupon was only good for a certain amount, he couldn't. I was purchasing one of their most expensive dog foods. Still he refused to honor it. I hope corporate shows Bryan where the door is. He argued with me in front of the store over $10!!!!
A few weeks ago I went there to get some fish for my 20 by 30 fish tank so I bought then I went home and activated the fish then the next morning my fish died
Will NEVER give this company my business Angry manager associates bashing the manager I was there to buy dog treats and it was a nightmare I was actually scared from the violent behavior of the manager got my refund and left.
I will only ship at Chewy zero problems have been shopping with Chewy for 13 years
Buying cat food and litter for my rescues racks up a lot of points. With those purchases, you can earn free bags of food and boxes of litter. You can also earn dollars off of your order-$5, $10, $20—until the boss decides to no longer honor any coupons from you saying you’re being investigated for fraudulent activity by using coupons THEY sent to you. Hello BBB…
The employees are kind and professional. Unfortunately, their boss won’t even return a phone call. She says she has but I do have an answering machine…
Had an autoship that didn't get cancelled in time so called store to see about refund and was told I could. Once I got to store neither employees or manager knew how to do it. Very un happy...have decoded to take my business elsewhere
Rewards program is a scam! You cannot redeem points. There are no instructions that work. No one at the store can help because they didn't join the program due to complexity. All they want is to collect your email address to track you!
Some Pet Supplies Plus locations host visiting veterinarians or have in-store vet clinics that offer basic services like vaccinations and wellness exams. Services vary by location, so check with your local store for availability and scheduling.
How can I find my nearest Pet Supplies Plus location?
You can find your nearest Pet Supplies Plus store by using the store locator on their website or mobile app. Simply enter your zip code or city to view nearby locations, contact information, and specific store services.
Does Pet Supplies Plus price match competitors?
Pet Supplies Plus offers competitive pricing and may price match certain competitors on identical items. Price matching policies may vary by location and require proof of competitor pricing, so contact your local store for specific details.
About Pet Supplies Plus
Pet Supplies Plus is a retail chain that specializes in pet supplies and accessories for various types of pets. The stores typically offer products such as pet food, toys, grooming supplies, bedding, and other essentials for dogs, cats, birds, fish, and small animals. Many locations also provide services like pet grooming and may carry live animals such as fish and small pets.