Etsy currently faces significant criticism from consumers, with a staggering 93% of reviews rating it 1 star. Many reviewers express frustration over the decline in product quality, noting that the platform is now filled with low-quality, imported items.
Read full summary
Show less
Customers report issues with seller reliability, including scams and poor product descriptions, leading to dissatisfaction with their purchases. Additionally, numerous complaints highlight problems with account management, such as unexpected suspensions and lack of support when issues arise. While a small number of users mention positive experiences with specific sellers and appreciate receiving Etsy credits, these positives are overshadowed by the overwhelming negative sentiment regarding the platform's overall service and product offerings.
1,000 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago
Where the score comes from
Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.
Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
Source
Rating
Reviews
Weight
6-mo
Fake risk
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
1.3
1,000
100%
-0.2
● Low
1.3 / 5 overall
=
1,000 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ
Reputation trend
Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Aug 2025.
Last 3 months
1.3▼ 0.2
12-month avg
1.3
All-time
1.3
Category avg
4.0
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
Month
Average
Reviews
Apr 25
1.4
178
May 25
1.4
240
Jun 25
1.3
252
Jul 25
1.2
278
Aug 25
1.4
52
What people praise & complain about
Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.
Top praiseof 29 positive reviews
Website & app28%
8 mentions
Customer service10%
3 mentions
Delivery10%
3 mentions
Quality7%
2 mentions
“I love them and think I received a better value from the Etsy vendors than buying from other websites”
On “Website & app” · Aug 4, 2025
Top complaintsof 465 negative reviews
Customer service25%
118 mentions
Account issues21%
99 mentions
Payment issues13%
61 mentions
Refund11%
52 mentions
“Etsy refused to pay my remaining balance after account suspension
My Etsy seller account was permanently suspended”
On “Customer service” · Aug 7, 2025
How it compares
Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Shopping & Fashion.
Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
er staan foto's met producten die je besteld met een goede omschrijving maar helaas je krijgt heel iets anders. maar dan kom je niet met een bedrijf in contact die het heeft geleverd dat is heel slecht met via esty moet je dan ook niets bestellen wamt je geld is weg en je hebt niet het product dat je wou hebben dus moet je naar een ander dus niet te vertrouwen
Etsy: Shop Banned Without Warning, Appeals Unanswered, and Money Taken for a New Shop That Was Instantly Suspended! Absolutely Appalling!
My experience selling on Etsy has been utterly terrible. I opened my shop on Etsy (SAMEXSTORE) less than two months ago. It was a new shop with low views, but I was already starting to get organic sales and even received a 5-star review, which was a very promising sign. Suddenly, and without any prior warning, email notification, or explanation whatsoever, Etsy permanently suspended my shop!
I am confident I did not violate any of Etsy's rules, and this irrational and unexplained shop closure has left me heartbroken. I immediately submitted an appeal to understand the reason and expressed my willingness to fix any issues, but I have received absolutely no response!
To make matters worse, I decided to try opening a new Etsy shop, using new information and intending to strictly follow all policies. However, as soon as Etsy processed payment from my credit card (for listing/setup fees), that new shop was instantly suspended too! This is not just disappointing; it feels like Etsy is 'siphoning money' from honest sellers trying to get started.
Etsy's lack of transparency in managing sellers is appalling. There's no communication, no warnings, and they arbitrarily shut down businesses. I've lost so much emotion, time, and money dealing with this platform!"
Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.
Bei mir ist der bestellte Artikel beschädigt angekommen - so das man diesen nicht mehr nutzen kann. Bei verkäufer auf der Seite stand - 14 Tage Rückgaberecht! Um den Verkäufer zu Kontaktieren - MUSS ich mich vorher bei ETSY anmelden - genau das habe ich getan. Als ich mich nach der Anmeldung einloggen wollte - war dies nicht möglich, und direkt danach bekamm ich eine Email in der Stand - mein Konto ist Gesperrt!! Nach einigen Emails mit dem Support von ETSY - wo ich mein Anliegen geschildert habe, und nach der Überprüfung Ihrerseits meines Accounts, bekamm ich folgende Antwort: "Nachdem ich Ihr Konto überprüft habe, sehe ich, dass es wegen Verstoßes gegen Etsys Nutzungsbedingungen dauerhaft gesperrt wurde, insbesondere aufgrund von Kontopraktiken, Verhalten oder Aktivitäten, die nicht unseren Richtlinien folgen."
Ich war nicht einmal eingeloggt gewesen!! Und komme ohne Account nicht an den Verkäufer heran.
Also das ist das letzte, solche Werbung zu machen und sobald ein Problem auftritt - die Leute zu Blockieren!!
Kann von dieser Seite nur Abraten!!!!
Leider gibts keine NULL STERNE - die wären hier genau Richtig !!
Purtroppo non posso dare 0 stelle
Mi sono iscritta ad Etsy Seller (la piattaforma per vendere), ho pagato diversi soldi per farlo, e dopo poche ore il mio account è stato bloccato. Da li non è più stato possibile fare niente, né parlare con nessuno di questo. TERRIBILE SERVIZIO. Vi sconsiglio fortemente di utilizzarlo
Refusing to take down shops they know are misleading people
Not only have they updates guidelines to hurt small sellers they are doing nothing to get rid of fake sellers. I just ordered from a small, handmade business located in NY and when I requested the shipping it is actually shipping from China. I reported the shop and filed for a refund and was told my the seller that is just the way "logistics" work and it is cheaper to ship from China... I went to their one star reviews and realized they've been doing this for a while and Etsy has done nothing. Unless you are 100% sure the business or person is who they say they are (linked to IG or a personal website do not buy from Etsy). I will never shop on Etsy again.
SCAM. None of 7 purchases arrived. Etsy lies that they protect customers. As a result my Pay Pal account was blocked and I still don;t have money and goods.
It was not made clear to me the amount of import duties I would have to pay, ordered a Turkish rug and paid £172 , but UPS wanted nearly £50 import duties upon delivery which I knew nothing about as it hadn’t been made clear to me ! I refused the order but kept getting messages from the vender wanting me to keep it . I had ordered it paying with karma as I couldn’t pay for it outright, so I have started refund from them , however the vender wants to charge me for delivery when it said it was free
We want to delete countries from shipping profles!
As a vintage and antiques seller on Etsy, I work with a wide range of item sizes and weights — which means I have to create multiple shipping profiles. I wanted to exclude France from my shipping destinations for legal and administrative reasons. Sounds simple? Not on Etsy.
Etsy refuses to provide sellers with a basic tool: the ability to block certain countries. The only way to exclude France is to manually input ALL other countries into each shipping profile - in my case, that’s about 190 countries × 12 profiles. Insane? Yes. But that's Etsy's policy.
Now, Etsy is threatening to send seller data to French tax authorities, while not allowing us to remove France from our shipping lists. What a way to treat the people who generate your revenue, right?
To make matters worse, their support team is deeply untrained. Two agents gave me incorrect instructions on how to remove a country - which wasted my time. Only the third admitted that it’s not even possible.
Etsy is making sellers jump through ridiculous hoops instead of offering reasonable, professional tools. Disappointing and frustrating.
I finally started to get decent sales after spending months of figuring out and bettering my business and today I woke up to not being able to log in to my account. I have no email or anything explaining why.. the only reason I know im suspended is because it says that when I try to log in to my etsy app for buying since selling app didn't even mention that when I repeatedly tried logging back in. I appealed but they said it's declined and they can't disclose why.....what the heck??????? So disappointed i gave so much of my time and efforts to grow on this platform and planning on building my business with them. So sad. Even if they would "take" me back i would never entertain them again. For the fees they are charging, not having customer service??? And all the wierd cr*p they allow on their website? I've been watching a bunch of true crime and they mentioned how when you fo on etsy and enter certain search words, some wierd things come up; like a random painting for example that costs 30,000 or more. And there are tons of things like that if you know the right keywords. The Channel i got this info from assumes it's human tra**icing of some sort.... buy etsy!
I was charged $19 by Etsy, marked as refundable, but I never got my money back.
Support told me to wait 9 days, then stopped responding. No refund, no help.
Be careful—don’t trust them with your payment info.
I won’t be using Etsy again.
J'ai commandé un lot de boutures végétales auprès d'un vendeur qualifié par Etsy de "top vendeur". N'ayant rien reçu plusieurs semaines après le délai prévu et l'entreprise refusant de s'expliquer, j'ai signalé la difficulté à la plateforme. La réaction d'Etsy s'est limitée à me demander après quelques jours si mon problème avec le vendeur était réglé, à quoi j'ai répondu négativement sans que la plateforme Etsy réagisse face à l'inconduite de son vendeur. Ce vendeur a depuis disparu de la plateforme.Je considère Etsy comme un site commercial irresponsable et ne le consulte plus désormais.
I was sent a message to say parcel delivered by Etsy at 10pm on Friday it definitely wasn’t delivered
The seller won’t help
Evry the courier company hasn’t got back to me in 72 hours
Etsys link to raise issue doesn’t work
I will never use Etsy again
My account is closed when I make a purchase. My purchase is being canceled. Why was an account I used myself, which I tried to shop for mysqlf, banned? I request that this problem I experienced white using your platform for the first time be resolved urgently.
Good Day.
Ordinata una maglia di un noto giocatore pagata 86€ La maglia non è arrivata e mi è stato bloccato l'account in modo da non poter richiedere il rimborso TRUFFATORI
Misleading listing and products, items take weeks to arrive
Sellers all seem to deceptive, trying to ask very high prices for tiny gold jewelry items, listing the price as the lowest quality metal but the actual gold item cost 4x as much. I bought $800 diamond earrings from India and the seller sent moissanite, ( had them tested at a jeweler) and he wouldn’t even own up to it. They all say there are items in stock but then they have to make it, they used the lowest quality materials they can. then on top of it they all mark the orders as shipped, and then don’t actually drop them off for weeks ! When you ask about why it shows in the tracking the label is printed and not sent they lie. I’m so over all of these people trying to trick naive buyers, lying. Not shipping. They’re all scammers
Der Kauf ging tadellos und der Verkäufer versand auch schnell. Jedoch Etsy selbst hat mein Konto gesperrt weil ich mehrere Male das Passwort falsch eingegeben habe. Sogar komplett. Sowas hab ich als Neukunde noch nicht erlebt. Einmal und nie wieder.
C'est le pire achat que j'ai fait, en trois jours le tableau magnétique est à jeter au poubelle. Je suis prêt à vous envoyer des photos de l'état de votre "magnifique" tableau au bout de trois jours. Je vous assure que je ne ferai plus d'achat chez vous sauf si vous m'envoyer un bon produit ou vous me rembourser. vous livrez un tableau couvert d'un scotch blanc pour écrire dessus, alors ça devait être une plaque de plexiglass. Les lettre se tordent au bout de deux jour. Très honteux vraiment
I've HAD it with ETSY sellers. This isn't the first time I leave an honest review only to have an Etsy seller personally contact me afterwards. They respond all polite in the review except blame everything on the customer because they are incapable of making a mistake. Yeah, great quality to have as a business owner lol. I'm sick and tired of sellers coming UNGLUED and personally attacking me over a review! Then you can't stop them from bothering you. You can't block all the unwanted messages. You can't report the shop to Etsy for having terrible customer service! Etsy needs to be policing their sellers and holding them to higher standards!
Cannot contact Etsy by phone if there is a problem
I have been with Etsy for many years. Had my site hacked and they got my credit card and ordered hundreds of dollars of Etsy merchandise. I tried to contact Etsy and only got texting with there dumb kids on the other end. No live people to talk with so I closed my account.
Etsy mit Sitz in Ireland ist schon eine Zumutung. Dies war mein erster und letzter Kauf. Der Kontakt mit der Verkäuferin war noch problemlos, die Rückzahlung schon beschwerlicher. Das Geld muss man sich über Etsy zurück holen, da fängt der Ärger an. Nichts zu finden für eine Rückzahlung und der Chat ausschließlich in englisch. Nein Danke! Gott sei Dank konnte es mit Paypal geklärt werden.