Skip to main content
Carolina Cabin Rentals logo

Carolina Cabin Rentals reviews & trust report

Carolina Cabin Rentals, Inc. is a family-owned vacation rental management company established in 2008, located in the northwest mountains of North Carolina. The company specializes in managing a diverse portfolio of over 430 cabin and vacation rental properties across popular destinations, including Boone, Blowing Rock, Banner Elk, and Beech Mountain. In addition to its primary focus on the North Carolina Blue Ridge Mountains, Carolina Cabin Rentals also offers properties near Lake Norman and Watauga Lake in Tennessee. The company provides comprehensive property management services for homeowners and vacationers alike. Its team of more than 75 full-time staff and 50+ contractors ensures a seamless rental experience, catering to families, groups, and individuals seeking a mountain getaway. With a commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, Carolina Cabin Rentals aims to connect travelers with ideal accommodations for their outdoor adventures.

Latest review over a year ago
CrowdTrust overview703 customer reviews

Carolina Cabin Rentals has a positive customer experience.

Carolina Cabin Rentals receives high praise for its beautiful cabins and excellent customer service, with many reviewers highlighting the cleanliness and comfort of the accommodations. Guests appreciate the spaciousness of the cabins, making them ideal for family gatherings, and the accurate online descriptions of the properties.

Read full summary

However, there are significant concerns regarding the company's strict cancellation policy, which has left some customers frustrated, especially in cases of emergencies like natural disasters. Reviewers also report poor communication and responsiveness from the staff, with several expressing dissatisfaction over unresolved issues during their stays. While many enjoy their experiences, the negative feedback regarding customer service and cancellation practices cannot be overlooked.

Summary generated with AI from recent reviews

Is it legit?
100
Strong signals
3 of 3 checks passed · see checks
Will I be happy?
4.7/ 5
Mostly positive
Recent reviews: 90% happy · 9% unhappy

Best for

  • Easy to use
  • Customer service
  • Fast & efficient

Watch out for

  • Refund
  • Customer service
  • Cancellation
703 customer reviewsLatest review over a year ago

Where the score comes from

Each source counts by its number of reviews. Only reviews written by people are scored.

Rating, volume, share of the score, six-month trend and fake-review risk for each source
SourceRatingWeight
Trustpilot
Imported Trustpilot reviews
4.7
100%
4.7 / 5 overall
703 reviews across 1 scored source
How fake risk works ⓘ

Reputation trend

Monthly average rating from reviews written by people · latest review Jan 2025.

Last 3 months
3.0▲ 2.0
12-month avg
2.0
All-time
4.7
Category avg
4.0
1.02.03.04.05.0Apr 24MayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecJan 25Category avg 4.0Apr 24: 5.0 from 1 reviewJun 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewOct 24: 1.0 from 4 reviewsNov 24: 1.0 from 1 reviewJan 25: 5.0 from 1 review
Monthly averageCategory average
Monthly average rating and review count
MonthAverageReviews
Apr 245.01
May 24—0
Jun 241.01
Jul 24—0
Aug 24—0
Sep 24—0
Oct 241.04
Nov 241.01
Dec 24—0
Jan 255.01

What people praise & complain about

Share of positive (4–5★) and negative (1–2★) reviews mentioning each topic · based on the 500 most recent reviews.

Top praiseof 449 positive reviews

  • Easy to use15%
    67 mentions
  • Customer service9%
    42 mentions
  • Fast & efficient8%
    35 mentions
  • Professionalism5%
    23 mentions
“Easy to book with”
On “Easy to use” · Jun 6, 2022

Top complaintsof 44 negative reviews

  • Refund43%
    19 mentions
  • Customer service34%
    15 mentions
  • Cancellation30%
    13 mentions
  • Payment issues27%
    12 mentions
“So, I proceeded the very next morning on the18th To notify Carolina Cabin rentals of the medical emergency and they e...”
On “Refund” · Nov 19, 2024

How it compares

Same method for every company: overall rating, legitimacy checks, the average rating of reviews mentioning each area and the 6-month trend · Vacation Rentals.

Overall rating and review count for this company and similar companies
CompanyOverallReviews
Carolina Cabin Rentals logo
Carolina Cabin Rentals
4.7 out of 5 (good)703
4.9 out of 5 (good)1,109
4.2 out of 5 (good)1,083
4.6 out of 5 (good)1,069
4.8 out of 5 (good)1,050

Bottom line: Carolina Cabin Rentals is #3 of 5 on overall rating in this group. On website & app, Audley Travel scores higher (5.0 vs 3.8).

Reviews

500 reviews of Carolina Cabin Rentals. Filter by what matters to you.

4.7ⓘ

Customer reviews (703)

0 reviews in the last 12 months

Write a review
Lisa Young
Lisa Young
1 review

The hot tub was a grave disappointment

The hot tub was a grave disappointment, the second day I received a text that it will get fixed after we leave. Also, the air conditioner stopped working, and my husband went out of his way to inform the repair guys on what was going on and told him how to fix it. My husband and I have been going to Blowing Rock for twenty years and have not experienced a stay like this one. Believe me, we won't book any future rentals from Carolina Cabins! Lisa Young

Report
RAMON
RAMON
1 review

book pay contract and BAMMMMM SCAMMM

I was so excited to spend a week in the mountains and i was so luck to have spoken to Morgan. Told me i would get a discount for renting a week, so i did. I picked a great cabin booked paid and gave a discount from 3,900 to 3,700 . I get the contract and when we are about to sign wrong last name no a biggy but we get a oh sorry wrong dates now we have to raise you from 3,700 to 4,300.WHAT? I spoke to Ed no compassion , i said this can not be look so i go in like a new booking guess what it saids on site i have the picture 3,900. So how could you rip us off wanting to charge us 4,300. I had to reach out to Amex do not sign anything until you read and get first the contract. Oh and conveniently you can not cancel if it is passed 24 hrs wow. So i write three emails, as well as ask for a supervisor. I am told will call you back this was 9 hours ago. I guess they noticed that they made a big mistake #don'ttrust

Report
gb
gb
1 review

Stick with VRBO and AIRBNB!

Our experience with Carolina Cabin Rentals was awful! Horrible customer service – they proved to us that they don’t care about their customers! If you are reading this and you haven’t rented from them yet – I recommend going with VRBO or AIRBNB!! We’ve had great experience with both of those organizations and will stick with them!! We rented a cabin from Carolina Cabin Rentals – Bears Creek Lodge - and it was a gorgeous cabin but it was very dirty in many areas. I sent an email to Carolina Cabin Rentals with pictures (so they could see it for themselves) explaining our experience. No response. I sent it again 2 weeks later and still no response. What kind of customer service is that? AWFUL! Plus, there is a $1000.00 security deposit when you rent and when they refund your deposit – they take out a $33.83 “administrative fee”. Just all around disappointing! If you want a good experience, DON’T use them!

Report
Marizol Martinez

Don't trust their 5-star rating

In April 2021, we stayed at a CCR property rated 5 stars, Parkway Retreat in Blowing Rock, NC. From the moment we walked in the door, it was clear this was not a 5-star rental (terrible smell from dirty diapers left in the trash). We uncovered a number of issues throughout our stay (not enough hot water for showers, clogged bath tubs, no heat in the basement with 2 bunk beds, among other things). At the end of our stay, I wrote a very comprehensive review to make sure others were forewarned. In spite of my many emails asking why my review and rating are still not reflected on the CCR site, and being told that they will be, here we are in August and Parkway Retreat still has a perfect 5-star rating. It seems clear to me that CCR doesn't really care about honest reviews. Be forewarned and don't trust any of their 5-star properties.

Report
Lillian Shvartsman

Unprofessional

Unprofessional. Give you wrong information. Use them only if you’re looking for problems.

Report
Toni Yates
Toni Yates
1 review

Bearadise beware

We booked Bearadise cabin because it had a hot tub. Before we were leaving for the trip, I noticed another review for a cabin with Carolina Cabins that said when the got to the cabin the hot tub wasn't working. I called the company and just 8 minutes before I called, the office was notified the hot tub wasn't working. I asked if we could change to a cabin with a working hot tub and was told there weren't any available. Talked to family then called back to see if my trip insurance would cover canceling. The second person I talked to said she thought it would, or we could call back and they would talk to the owners about a discount- oh and they gave us $75 for the hot tub not working. Long story short, the insurance denied the claim saying it was the owners issue. Several emails later we have still not gotten any type of refund. I honestly would have been happy with a partial refund. Whether it was Red Sky insurance, the cabin owners, or Carolina Cabin rentals who knows.... poor business either way. This group can really pass the buck.

Report
Michelle Foster

HUGE Disappointment

Huge disappoint all the way around! We have traveled to the area on numerous occasions, but never rented from this company. The pictures of the home were a far stretch from the actual state of the home. Upon arrival, the furniture was completely disorganized, the couch was covered in feathers/lint, the steps to the hot tub were covered in ice, there were berry few cooking pots/pans and the dishwasher was filled with half of the dishes dirty. We had to purchase ice and spend over 2 hours busting up the ice on the stairs. Additionally, the maintenance man showed up as we checked in (approximately 30 minutes earlier than normal check in) and had to drain the hot tub because it was cloudy and dirty - which resulted in us not being able to use the hot tub until Day 2. Once the hot tub finally heated up, it wasn’t maintaining heat. One of the reasons we booked this place was to enjoy the hot tub which was a huge disappointment because we could only use for 2 hours the weekend. Before arriving, two people at the rental office indicated the house had been empty for an entire week. So it is beyond frustrating that they would wait until the day of check in to clean the house and check the hot tub. Furthermore, we were only provided one towel per person and one roll of toilet paper per bathroom. The manager offered to refund us $75 because of the hot tub issue, which is thoughtful, but unfortunately that wasn’t enough given the other issues we encountered. We will be booking rentals in the future with the companies we previously used.

Report
Mari Villasuso

We are rented in a property from Carolina Cabin Rentals

We are rented in a property from Carolina Cabin Rentals in the Boone area, we were lucky enough to get 5-6 inches of snow on Christmas Eve, that created a series of problems to our cabin that left us with out running water for 2 days now. We’re a family of 8; contacted the owner of the cabin and the rental company “CCR” they’re trying to get a plumber for two days now. ALL of us are getting frustrated because of the vacation is turning out to be the vacation from HELL and the worth is that we rented for a week... we got together and poured salt on the driveway to be able to get the car out now we can’t get the car back up because ice and a neighbor is complaining because we can’t have the car in the entrance of the driveway. We’re not happy with the handling of our water problem; salt is needed to clear the ice in the driveway and CCR is taking too long to resolve our problem. We need to shower, flush toilets and ultimately the water bottles are helping to brush our teeth. I do not recommend the CCR. The problem is not the cabin the problem is the handling of the situation...

Report
Addison Apperson

Horrible experience with this company

Horrible experience with this company. We booked a cabin house on Airbnb and paid our deposit. 2 weeks after paying and booking I received a call from a woman from this company. She started our conversation by asking me many questions and interrogating me and trying to figure out what rules we would be breaking once we got there. After finding out that we would not be breaking any rules, she revealed the real reason that she was calling. The company had double booked the cabin we had rented. It was clear then that the woman was trying to find a reason to make us cancel our reservation so we Would not get a full refund and they would still make money off of our group. This was clear when she insinuated we would be breaking rules when we got there So we would cancel. After telling us they had double booked, she still attempted to make money off of us by telling us that we needed to go in and cancel the cabin. She told us this knowing that if we cancelled for their mistake, they would still be able to make money. When realizing that we were not stupid and Would not cancel it ourselves, she told us she would figure something out and call us back. An hour later we received a cancellation email and no further communication from this company. It is incredibly unprofessional to run a business this way and to not take accountability for the mistakes you make. It is also very unprofessional to list the house on two websites and not take the house off of the other website when it was booked and paid for. This company will never be getting my money again and I hope in the future they are able to run their business in a more professional manner.

Report
Monica Brakha

we rented this house for our summer…

we rented this house for our summer vacations, we had several problems, and it was a terrible service, they didn't send us anyone to fix it, and they said it was fine for them, we have a photo of everything .. very bad service I don't recommend this house at all

Report
Alex B
Alex B
1 review

WORST RENTAL EVER IN MY LIFE

WORST RENTAL EVER IN MY LIFE. NO CUSTOMER SERVICE AT ALL. FOR THEM AN AC THAT COOL AT 80F IS WORKING WELL IF OUTSIDE IS 90F. AND THEY ONLY MAKE EXCUSE WHEN YOU CALL FOR HELP. Alex B.

Report
PATTI HATZIMOURATIDES

Canceled our November vacation at…

Canceled our November vacation at Summit View 17 days after making $928 deposit due to Florida where we reside , becoming the Global Hotspot for Covid19. After contacting Carolina Cabins they contacted the owners but they refused to refund the deposit in full. 50% was their response! We believe that Greed played a part in this decision and we were doing the right thing not to travel and especially stay where we could possibly spread the virus to other unsuspecting visitors. We are very disappointed and will never stay at their property nor will any of the numerous family & friends that we know. Summit View is a beautiful place but the heart’s of the owners are cold and greedy. Beware people.

Report
Margie Walker

The location was great

The location was great. The house was good. BUT the communication was lacking. This is an email we sent them on AirBNB a day after we left the house and it has been three weeks and we have yet to hear back from them Thank you for a good week, I wanted to write to you with some concerns about our stay. I decided to enjoy the last two days of my vacation as much as I could and not contact you again while we were there. As you know there were things that we were very dissapointed in and this is why... When we started looking for places to stay back in January we had multiple things on our list that we were looking for and your cabin met all of our needs. The reason for our trip was to celebrate our moms 60th birthday. Three families were coming together to celebrate. My mom really wanted a grill to for a BBQ. Which yall had. But when we got there...it was disgusting. And Andrew (my husband) took 45 minutes to an hour to clean it. He said it was one of the worst grills he has ever seen. Which was disappointing. We also wanted a hot tub. Which your place had but it was dirty when we got there. And we are not even sure it had been serviced in between stays. I know now I should have taken a picture and reported it right away but this is the first time I have stayed with a hot tub. It just was not very clean and the water level was low. I asked multiple times about the water level and it was not until Wednesday that I heard back that I was able to add water to it. With no mention of a hose on site so I used a pot from the kitchen to make several trips to and from the hot tub to fill it up. When we mentioned the bubbles (which yall said were normal) to Kevin he said they were not normal and it needed to be serviced. Which he did and they went away. Which again tells us that it was not serviced in between visits. Which is disgusting. Third we were really excited about the outside living area. One of the things we were looking forward to being from Texas was sitting outside in the cool Temps and enjoying the mountain air. When we got there it looked as if the furniture or picnic table had not been wiped down in a very long time. The wipes we used were black after we wiped everything down. Also the outside furniture needs a serious update. It was in no way comfortable to sit in. Also the fireplace did not work. We tried to get it to work and spent quite sometime working on it. I mentioned this to you on Monday morning and it was n9t until Wednesday night that someone came out to fix the situation. That meant more than half of our vacation was gone and we had not been able to enjoy the fireplace outside. Fourth. The firepit! It clearly states in your listing that there is an outside gas fireplace AND a fire pit that we can purchase wood for. Why would we need to purchase fire wood for a gas fireplace. When Kevin came we asked him about it and he said there use to be a portable firepit That was no longer there. Which was very disaapointing. One because we were bought and brought ingredients for smores and little kids who were excited to make them over a campfire. And two because we were told it was there. Then we looked and looked and looked and looked multiple times (using up our vacation) to look for a.firepit that was advertised that was not there. And then we mentuoned it over and over and over again yall told us it was the gas fireplace that that was talking about. Which was not true. Disappointing. Fifth! Half of the TVs did not work. We were only able to get half of them to work and we spent quite a while with to no avail on the others. And the one on the patios remote did not work. We were only able to change channels from the box. Sixth. There was no internet in the extra guest house. This would have been nice to know. We were looking forward to doing a movie night in there with the grandkids and their grandma but because we were not able to use our laptop's internet or use the TV which did not work we were not able to do that activity. There was a DVD player but unfortunately we did not have any dvds for movie night. My mom who stayed in there was never able to use any of her devices when she was there in the evening either. SAD. Also...just so you are aware...in front of the guest house when it rains the front porch fills up with mud. That might be something you need to repair and look into. We loved Beech Mountain but we are not sure if we would stay at the Stettin House again or even any of the properties from Carolina Cabin Rentals. We paid a lot of money and I feel like a lot of my vacation was spent with communicating back and forth with you guys and nothing really being done about it until after the third or fourth time asking. Honestly, nothing was fixed until after the 4th day we were there. And now we are heading home from our trip and there are still things on that list that we never got. For example the firepit.

Report
Nadine Toosbuy Fairbrother

Would not rent from them again

I have no doubt that all the properties are wonderful and we are very much looking forward to staying at one of the beautiful homes next week. But I have to stay having dealt with several rental companies throughout the years as well as owning rental properties, I am not a fan of Carolina Cabins. First, our reservation was originally canceled due to the pandemic and of course we completely understood. What I didn’t understand was that Carolina Cabins charged me $75 to cancel the reservation. They stated it was their administrative fees. So my reservation was canceled by them and I was still charged $75. I would have understood had I been the one to cancel. Then I requested early check in since the house was free of tenants for the few days prior to our arrival. Check in is 4pm. In order to check in around 1pm into a vacant property, they once again wanted to charge me an early check in fee of $75. I have never been so nickeled and dimed with a rental company and if it was not for attempting to recoup my original $75 in administrative fees, I would not have rented from them. And as lovely as their properties look, I will never rent from them again.

Report
Christine Schaub

Refunds

I have had a HORRIBLE experience with this company. I was extremely excited for the first time renting a cabin, we drove 6 hours one way each just to look at these cabins and in person they are beautiful so we booked. Three days after we booked the Covid pandemic hit and I lost my job. I immediately cancelled and did everything I was suppose to after shelling out over 2000 dollars for this event. I was told that I can get 50 percent back. My next question is how do I get my other half back or are there options to reschedule, push the date back, anything. Something. The answer I received from an employee is "it already went to the owners and they dont give money back". My response is, " I am not cancelling because i changed my mind I had no way of knowing about this virus and losing my job" the employees response was "well I can read you the section of the contract where it says where the money goes". I was floored. I never take the time to write reviews, but I am so extremely disappointed in the service of this company. Never again will I even consider using this company or anything affiliated with this company. A 1000 dollars out and absolutely no room to schedule at another time. PLEASE when you book make sure you are 100 percent sure this is what you want because if its not you will be left out a serious amount of money!!!

Report
Kyle Schicker

Will not accommodate amidst covid 19.

Will not accommodate amidst covid 19.

Report
Gerald Schicker

After 20 Years

we have been vacationing in the Boone, Banner Elk area for over 20 years. This is the 1st time we have had to cancel our vacation. Our sole reason is because of the Covid 19 virus my wife and I will have been out of work for over two months leading to our vacation.There is no way to make any more payments so we had hoped due to circumstances beyond our control that Carolina Cabin Rentals would either hold our full deposit for a future rental or return our full deposit. They informed us that the refund policy is unwavering. So sad to see the lack of humanity during this crisis. Scott Schicker

Report
Keith Carnahan

Coronavirus scammer

The cancelation policy for the Coronavirus situation is terrible. Will never use this service again and I warn anyone of using their service. It is very sad for a business to take advantage of a situation like this to not be accommodating to their customers. If I was you go to another place to rent.

Report

Alternatives to Carolina Cabin Rentals

You Might Also Be Interested In

The CrowdTrust Experience⭐

Anyone can write a CrowdTrust review. People who write reviews have ownership to edit or delete them at any time, and they'll be displayed as long as an account is active.